Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars
Country Of Origin: United States
Synopsis
In 1868 and Sherlock Holmes in fourteen. When two people die of symptoms that resemble the plague, Holmes begins to investigate and find out what really happened.
Review
Who Writes Death Cloud?
Andrew Lane is an author, journalist and lifelong Sherlock Holmes fan. He lives in Hampshire with his wife and son. Before Moriarty and before Benedict Cumberbatch, Andrew's passion for the original novels of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and his determination to create an authentic teenage Sherlock Holmes made him the perfect choice to reinvent the world’s most famous detective for the Young Sherlock Holmes series.
What Is Death Cloud About?
With Death Cloud, Andrew Lane takes on what might seem like an impossible task: writing a Sherlock Holmes novel when the world's most famous detective has not yet become a detective. Officially authorised by the Conan Doyle Estate, the Young Sherlock Holmes series carries the seal of approval of Holmes' original custodians, and Lane uses that freedom to explore a side of the character that Arthur Conan Doyle never really examined.
What we get is Sherlock before Baker Street, before Dr Watson, and before the deductive genius became world famous. In Death Cloud, Sherlock is still a teenager, and perhaps the most interesting aspect of the novel is watching those famous skills develop. Lane cleverly shows that Holmes is already observant, intelligent and curious, but he is still learning how to apply those talents. This is Sherlock in training rather than Sherlock at his peak.
Naturally, this means the novel is aimed at a younger audience than most Sherlock Holmes pastiches. Sherlock's age mirrors the intended readership, and the result is a book that is highly accessible and easy to read. Younger readers can identify with the protagonist while still enjoying the mystery and adventure elements.
The writing style reflects this target audience. Despite being set in Victorian Britain, Death Cloud does not immerse itself heavily in the language or atmosphere of the period. There are few attempts to recreate Victorian speech patterns or employ historical colloquialisms. Purists might find this disappointing, but it makes the novel far more approachable for modern readers. The story moves quickly and never gets bogged down in historical detail.
As a historical novel, therefore, it is relatively light on atmosphere. Victorian England provides the backdrop, but the setting rarely becomes a major character in the story. Lane's priority is keeping the narrative moving and ensuring that readers remain engaged with Sherlock's adventure.
Fortunately, the plot is strong enough to achieve exactly that. The central mystery involving a deadly disease outbreak provides plenty of intrigue, while the supporting cast introduces several memorable characters who help shape Sherlock's development. The book also does an excellent job of laying the foundations for the detective Holmes will eventually become, showing how his experiences as a teenager contribute to the methods and personality readers know from the original stories.
Perhaps the novel's greatest success is that it feels like Sherlock Holmes without requiring Sherlock to actually be Sherlock Holmes yet. Lane captures the essence of the character while still allowing him room to grow and make mistakes.
Death Cloud is an engaging and accessible introduction to Andrew Lane's Young Sherlock Holmes series. While it places more emphasis on adventure than on recreating the atmosphere of Victorian Britain, it succeeds in presenting a believable young version of Conan Doyle's famous detective. Easy to read, packed with interesting characters and anchored by a compelling mystery, it serves as an entertaining entry point for younger readers and Holmes fans curious to see how the great detective's story might have begun.


No comments:
Post a Comment