Friday, February 27, 2026

Book Review: The Bone Collector Jeffery Deaver (Lincoln Rhyme 1) * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

Once the nation's foremost criminologist and the ex-head of NYPD forensics, quadriplegic Lincoln Rhyme abandons his forced retirement and joins forces with rookie cop Amelia Sachs to track down a vicious serial killer.



Review

Who Writes The Bone Collector?

Jeffery Deaver is an international number-one bestselling author. His novels have appeared on bestseller lists around the world. His books are sold in 150 countries and translated into over twenty-five languages. He has served two terms as president of Mystery Writers of America, and was recently named a Grand Master of MWA, whose ranks include Agatha Christie, Ellery Queen, Mary Higgins Clark and Walter Mosely.

What Is The Bone Collector About?

The Bone Collector is the first novel in Jeffrey Deaver's hugely successful Lincoln Rhyme series and immediately establishes many of the elements that would make the books stand out in the crowded crime-fiction market. Blending forensic science, serial-killer thrills and a vividly realised New York setting, it remains one of Deaver's strongest and most influential novels.

At the centre of the story is Lincoln Rhyme, the former head of NYPD forensics. Once one of the brightest investigative minds in law enforcement, Rhyme has been left quadriplegic following an on-duty accident. His injuries have taken a toll not only on his body but also on his mental state. Isolated, frustrated and struggling with thoughts of suicide, Rhyme is a deeply damaged protagonist whose brilliance is matched only by his despair.

Everything changes when a particularly challenging case comes his way. Along with rookie police officer Amelia Sachs, Rhyme becomes embroiled in the hunt for a sadistic serial killer. Sachs serves as Rhyme's eyes and ears at crime scenes, collecting evidence and carrying out the physical investigative work that Rhyme can no longer perform himself.

The partnership between Rhyme and Sachs is one of the novel's greatest strengths. Their relationship develops naturally over the course of the story, with Sachs evolving from an uncertain patrol officer into a highly skilled investigator. The dynamic between the two carries much of the narrative and would become a cornerstone of the series.

As the title suggests, The Bone Collector is very much a forensic thriller. Deaver fills the novel with detailed discussions of evidence recovery, crime-scene analysis and scientific investigation. Yet despite the technical detail, the book never feels dry or overly academic. Deaver has a rare ability to make forensic science exciting, turning the tiniest fragment of evidence into a crucial clue in the hunt for the killer.

Balancing this procedural side of the story are chapters told from the perspective of the murderer. Initially, these sections can seem like little more than filler or a device to increase the page count. However, they soon prove their worth by providing a chilling contrast to the logical, methodical work of Rhyme and Sachs. While the investigators rely on science and reason, the killer is driven by obsession and cruelty, creating an effective tension throughout the novel.

The setting is equally important. This is unmistakably a New York novel. Deaver uses the city brilliantly, weaving its history, geography and atmosphere directly into the investigation. The story could technically be relocated elsewhere, but it would lose much of its identity in the process. The city feels as essential to the novel as any of the characters.

The pacing is relentless, with twists, revelations and moments of genuine suspense keeping the reader engaged throughout. While later Lincoln Rhyme novels would sometimes become increasingly elaborate, The Bone Collector strikes an excellent balance between character, mystery and action.

Ultimately, The Bone Collector succeeds because it combines an intriguing detective partnership, fascinating forensic detail and a memorable villain with a strong sense of place. It launched one of modern crime fiction's most popular series for good reason.

A gripping and intelligent forensic thriller that introduced one of crime fiction's most distinctive detectives. With a compelling partnership between Lincoln Rhyme and Amelia Sachs, fascinating investigative detail and a vividly realised New York setting, The Bone Collector remains a modern crime-fiction classic.





Friday, February 20, 2026

TV Series Review: Agatha Christie's Seven Dials * * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom





Synopsis

Lady Eileen Bundle investigates when a suspicious death occurs following a country house party and friends play a practical joke on the deceased by placing seven alarm clocks in his room.

Review

What is Agatha Christie's Seven Dials About?

With the small screen having already received what many would consider definitive portrayals of Agatha Christie's two most famous detectives, Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple, broadcasters have increasingly been forced to look elsewhere within Christie's extensive catalogue for material to adapt. In recent years, the BBC has led the way with adaptations of some of Christie's standalone novels, while Seven Dials marks Netflix's first significant venture into the world of Agatha Christie.

Based on The Seven Dials Mystery, the series is presented as a three-episode drama and brings one of Christie's lesser-known works to a modern audience. Given that the source material is a standalone novel rather than part of an ongoing series, it seems unlikely that Seven Dials will return for future instalments, unless television writers decide to expand beyond Christie's original work, something that is not unheard of in the television industry.

As an adaptation, Seven Dials remains surprisingly faithful to the novel. Fans of the book will find all of the major characters and key plot developments intact. The essence of Christie's mystery remains firmly at the heart of the series, ensuring that readers familiar with the original will recognise both the story and the eventual destination of the plot.

Where the adaptation differs is in the way it expands certain aspects of the narrative. The novel itself is relatively concise, and the television version takes the opportunity to flesh out both characters and scenes. This means there are moments in the series that do not appear in the book, but most of these additions feel natural rather than intrusive.

One of the most successful improvements is the treatment of Lady Eileen "Bundle" Brent. In the novel, Bundle is already an engaging amateur detective, but the television series gives her investigation greater focus and clarity. As a result, she feels more central to the story and emerges as a stronger and more proactive character than she sometimes appears on the page.

The production values are also impressive. This is a lavish period drama packed with familiar British acting talent, beautifully realised costumes and elegant settings. The production captures the glamour and charm of the interwar period while retaining the mystery and intrigue that Christie fans expect.

Perhaps the greatest compliment that can be paid to the series is that it understands the tone of the source material. While The Seven Dials Mystery has often stood somewhat in the shadow of Christie's more famous works, this adaptation demonstrates that it contains all the ingredients necessary for an entertaining television mystery.

Ultimately, Agatha Christie's Seven Dials is a faithful and enjoyable adaptation that successfully brings one of Christie's lesser-known novels to life. It may not achieve the iconic status of Poirot or Marple, but it offers an engaging mystery wrapped in a beautifully produced period drama.

A stylish and faithful adaptation that expands upon Agatha Christie's original novel without losing its charm. Strong performances, excellent production values and a more fully realised Lady Eileen Bundle make Seven Dials an enjoyable addition to the growing catalogue of Christie adaptations. 

Thursday, February 19, 2026

Book Review: The Seven Dials Mystery Agatha Christie * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Gerry Wade had proved himself to be a champion sleeper; so the other house guests decided to play a practical joke on him. Eight alarm clocks were set to go off, one after the other, starting at 6.30 a.m. But when morning arrived, one clock was missing and the prank had backfired with tragic consequences.  For Jimmy Thesiger in particular, the words ‘Seven Dials’ were to take on a new and chilling significance…



Review

Who Wrote The Seven Dials Mystery?

Born in Torquay in 1890, Agatha Christie began writing during the First World War and wrote over 100 novels, plays and short story collections. She was still writing to great acclaim until her death, and her books have now sold over a billion copies in English and another billion in over 100 foreign languages. Yet Agatha Christie was always a very private person, and though Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple became household names, the Queen of Crime was a complete enigma to all but her closest friends.

What is The Seven Dials Mystery About?

The Seven Dials Mystery is one of Agatha Christie's standalone novels and, unlike much of her most famous work, features neither Hercule Poirot nor Miss Marple. Instead, Christie returns to familiar territory in another sense, setting her story amongst the wealthy upper classes of English society.

The novel revolves around the household of Lord and Lady Coote and their country estate, where a practical joke involving a collection of alarm clocks results in a young man, Gerry Wade, being found dead in a locked bedroom. Alongside the body are seven alarm clocks, seemingly providing the setup for what could have been a classic Christie impossible-crime puzzle.

Unfortunately, the novel never quite follows through on that promise.

At first, The Seven Dials Mystery appears to be heading towards a locked-room mystery. The image of a dead man in a locked room surrounded by seven alarm clocks is certainly intriguing and immediately captures the imagination. Yet Christie seems surprisingly uninterested in developing this aspect of the story. The seven clocks themselves, despite giving the novel its title, play a much smaller role than readers might expect, and the circumstances of Gerry Wade's death are not investigated with the intensity typical of her best mysteries.

Instead, the novel gradually shifts its focus towards secret societies, conspiracies and shadowy organisations. The Seven Dials Club itself becomes more important than the murder that initially drew readers in. This gives the novel something of an adventure-thriller flavour rather than the tightly constructed detective puzzle for which Christie is best known.

There is also a great deal of attention paid to the lifestyles and social interactions of the upper classes. Christie was always comfortable writing about this world, and much of the novel's charm comes from the witty exchanges and colourful characters inhabiting it. In many ways, the social comedy is more memorable than the mystery itself.

The problem is that the central crime often feels forgotten amidst all the intrigue. Readers expecting a traditional investigation may find themselves wondering when the murder mystery is actually going to reassert itself. The book feels less focused than Christie's masterpieces, and the various conspiracies sometimes appear to distract from the more interesting puzzle at its heart.

That said, the novel remains highly readable. Christie was incapable of writing a dull book, and her ability to keep pages turning is on full display here. The recent reprint editions published in conjunction with modern adaptations make it especially easy to appreciate the brisk pacing and light touch that characterise much of her early work.

The cast is enjoyable, the dialogue sharp, and the story moves quickly enough that the shortcomings of the mystery never become fatal. It simply falls short of the standards set by Christie's finest novels.

The Seven Dials Mystery is an entertaining but ultimately second-tier Agatha Christie novel. The intriguing setup of a dead man in a locked room with seven alarm clocks promises a classic mystery that never quite materialises. Instead, Christie delivers a fast-paced blend of upper-class comedy, secret societies and conspiracy thriller elements. While it lacks the precision and brilliance of her greatest works, it remains an enjoyable read thanks to Christie's trademark wit and storytelling skill. Not essential Christie, but certainly an entertaining one.




Wednesday, February 18, 2026

Film Review: Knives Out * * *


 Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

Famed detective Benoit Blanc is summoned to investigate following the death of world famous mystery writer Harlan Thrombey



Review

Who Writes Knives Out?


Knives Out was written and directed by Rian Johnson.

What is Knives Out About?

Few modern films have embraced the spirit of the Golden Age murder mystery as enthusiastically as Knives Out. From its sprawling country-house setting to its cast of suspicious relatives, it feels like a loving tribute to the novels of Agatha Christie while simultaneously updating the formula for a modern audience.

Everything about the setup screams classic detective fiction. Wealthy crime novelist Harlan Thrombey is found dead in his mansion, and gathered around him is a family of potential suspects, each with their own motives, grievances and financial interests. It is exactly the sort of story Christie built a career upon, and fans of traditional whodunnits will immediately recognise the influences.

At the centre of the investigation is Benoit Blanc, a detective who feels as though he has wandered out of the 1920s and into the twenty-first century. Like Hercule Poirot, Blanc is eccentric, highly intelligent and possessed of an extraordinary ability to see patterns that others overlook. Daniel Craig clearly relishes the role, creating a detective who is both entertaining and memorable without simply becoming an imitation of Christie’s famous Belgian sleuth.

Although Knives Out is firmly set in the modern era, it does its best to keep many aspects of the modern world at arm's length. The focus remains on character, motive and deduction rather than technology. The result is a film that feels timeless despite dealing with contemporary issues and modern social dynamics. In many respects, the story could easily have been told decades earlier.

What is particularly impressive is how Rian Johnson updates the genre without abandoning its roots. The film understands why classic murder mysteries endure while also recognising that contemporary audiences expect something a little different.

This leads directly to what may be the film's most divisive decision.

Traditionally, murder mysteries invite viewers to solve the crime alongside the detective. Knives Out takes a different approach by revealing a crucial part of what appears to have happened relatively early in the film. For some viewers, this removes much of the puzzle-solving aspect. Instead of asking "Who did it?", much of the film becomes concerned with the consequences of what happened and whether the apparent truth is really the complete story.

As a result, there are times when it can feel as though the audience has been denied the opportunity to fully participate in the mystery. The traditional challenge of trying to identify the killer before the detective is largely replaced by a different type of suspense.

Fortunately, Johnson is far too clever a writer to leave things there. The film gradually reveals that there are still surprises waiting ahead, culminating in a final twist that recontextualises much of what has gone before. That ending gives the film the additional payoff it needs and rewards viewers for sticking with it.

The supporting cast is also excellent, with each family member bringing their own blend of entitlement, greed and dysfunction to proceedings. Even when the mystery takes a back seat, the characters remain entertaining enough to carry the story.

Knives Out is a stylish and highly entertaining homage to the Golden Age murder mystery. Its country-house setting, colourful suspects and eccentric detective feel delightfully old-fashioned, while its modern sensibilities keep the formula fresh. The decision to reveal key plot details early may frustrate viewers looking for a pure whodunnit, but the strong performances, witty script and satisfying final twist ensure that it remains a worthy addition to the crime fiction canon. Fans of Agatha Christie will find much to enjoy, even if the mystery plays by slightly different rules.

TV Series Review: Castle * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

Mystery writer Richard Castle begins working with thr NYPD after a serial killer uses his books as inspiration for his crimes.

Review

Who Writes Castle?

Castle was broadcast on the ABC network in the United States.  

What is Castle About?

Castle absolutely nails the crime-comedy formula. At a time when many detective dramas were becoming darker, grittier and increasingly obsessed with troubled detectives, Castle arrived with a refreshing sense of fun. The result was one of the most entertaining crime series of its era and a modern update of the classic Murder, She Wrote concept, placing a mystery writer at the heart of real-life murder investigations.

The premise is wonderfully simple. Richard Castle, a bestselling crime novelist, begins accompanying NYPD detective Kate Beckett on investigations as inspiration for a new series of books. From this starting point, the series develops into a mixture of police procedural, comedy, romance and crime-fiction satire.

What makes Castle stand out is that it never takes itself too seriously. The show delights in poking fun at both its own premise and the wider crime-fiction genre. Castle's endless theories often range from the plausible to the completely absurd, and the writers clearly enjoy lampooning the clichés of detective stories. For crime-fiction fans, there are countless references and in-jokes throughout the series.

Particularly enjoyable are the appearances from real-life crime writers. The show attracted cameos from several well-known authors, including James Patterson, playing himself rather than an actor portraying him. These moments demonstrate the affection that Castle has for the genre and add an extra layer of enjoyment for mystery readers.

Of course, the real reason the series worked for so long was the chemistry between Richard Castle and Kate Beckett. Nathan Fillion and Stana Katic create a partnership that is funny, engaging and believable throughout much of the show's run. Their constant banter, mutual respect and underlying attraction become the emotional engine that drives the series.

What remains remarkable is how natural their on-screen relationship appears given later reports that Fillion and Katic allegedly had a difficult off-screen relationship. Whatever happened behind the scenes, it rarely shows on screen, where their performances remain one of the show's greatest strengths.

The mysteries themselves are generally entertaining rather than groundbreaking. Few episodes reinvent crime television, but that hardly matters. The joy of Castle comes from spending time with the characters and watching them bounce off one another while solving murders.

The show's popularity eventually extended beyond television. Castle's fictional Nikki Heat novels, the very books that supposedly justified his involvement in police investigations, proved so popular with viewers that they were actually published as real books. It is difficult to think of many television series that have managed to blur the line between fiction and reality quite so successfully.

Ultimately, Castle succeeds because it understands that crime drama should also be fun. It combines humour, mystery, romance and self-awareness in a way that few series have managed before or since.

A hugely entertaining crime-comedy that blends murder mysteries with sharp humour and wonderful character chemistry. Bolstered by Nathan Fillion and Stana Katic's performances, Castle remains one of the most enjoyable and rewatchable detective series ever made.


Book Review: Triptych Karin Slaughter (Will Trent 1) * * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

When Atlanta police detective Michael Ormewood is called out to a murder scene, he finds himself faced with one of the most brutal killings of his career. A young woman, Aleesha Monroe, found dead in a pool of her own blood... her body horribly mutilated.  As a one-off killing it's shocking, but it soon becomes clear Aleesha is just the latest victim in a series of similar attacks.



Review

Who Writes Triptych?

Karin Slaughter is the New York Times and the No 1 best selling author of Faithless.  A native of Georgia she is currently working on many novels.

What Is Triptych About?

Triptych marks the beginning of Karin Slaughter's long-running Will Trent series and introduces readers to one of modern crime fiction's most distinctive investigators. At least, it does eventually introduce him. Surprisingly for a novel that launches a major detective series, Will Trent is not nearly as central to the story as readers might expect.

Will is a Special Agent with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, a statewide law enforcement agency, and he arrives to investigate a series of brutal killings. Beyond his role and profession, however, very little is revealed about him. Readers looking for an in-depth introduction to the character may come away slightly frustrated. Slaughter keeps much of Trent's background hidden, leaving him as something of an enigma throughout much of the novel.

What Triptych does exceptionally well is establish tone. This is not a cosy mystery, nor even a conventional police procedural. It is a dark, gritty and often disturbing crime novel that pulls very few punches. The violence is brutal, the subject matter uncomfortable, and the emotional fallout feels painfully real. Slaughter does not sanitise the realities of crime, and the novel is all the more powerful for it.

Interestingly, the book focuses less on the mechanics of the investigation than many readers might expect. While there is certainly a murder case to solve, Slaughter's primary interest lies in the people caught up in the crime. The narrative spends considerable time exploring the lives, motivations and psychological scars of its characters. In many ways, Triptych is as much a character study as it is a thriller.

This approach works well because the characters are so vividly written. Slaughter has always excelled at creating flawed, believable individuals, and that talent is evident throughout the novel. The emotional intensity often overshadows the procedural elements, making the story feel more personal and immediate.

The downside is that Will Trent himself can feel somewhat underused. For the protagonist of a future series, he spends surprisingly little time driving the narrative. He is present, certainly, but often feels more like one piece of a larger ensemble than the clear focal point of the book. Given how important he would become to the series, readers may wish Slaughter had spent more time developing him here.

Still, this is clearly a deliberate choice. Triptych is not trying to establish a larger-than-life detective hero in the mould of Reacher, Bosch or Alex Cross. Instead, it prioritises the story and the people affected by it, allowing Will to emerge gradually rather than forcing him into the spotlight.

The result is a novel that can be difficult to read at times because of its bleakness, but one that is impossible to dismiss. Slaughter's combination of strong characterisation, emotional depth and unflinching realism makes for a compelling experience.

Triptych is a dark, powerful and often unsettling crime novel that serves as the foundation for the Will Trent series. While readers may be surprised by how little they actually learn about Trent himself, the richly drawn characters and brutally effective storytelling more than compensate. Slaughter focuses on people rather than procedure, creating a gripping and emotionally charged thriller that announces the arrival of an important new voice in crime fiction. It may not be the definitive Will Trent novel, but it is certainly a memorable beginning.




Tuesday, February 10, 2026

Book Review: The Never Game Jeffery Deaver (Colter Shaw 1) * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

Sophie is locked inside a derelict warehouse.  Henry is abandoned in remote woodland.  Elizabeth is trapped inside a sinking ship.  They are alive, but don’t have much time to live… Only one man can save them: unique investigator Colter Shaw. He’s an expert tracker with a forensic mind, but this will be a test even for him.



Review

Who Writes The Never Game?

Jeffery Deaver is the international best selling author of more than thirty five novels.  His first novel The Bone Collector featuring Lincoln Rhyme has been made into a film.  He's received and been short listed for a number of awards around the world.

What is The Never Game About?

With The Never Game, Jeffrey Deaver launches what would become his fifth major series protagonist, introducing readers to Colter Shaw, a character who is refreshingly different from the detectives, police officers and forensic experts that dominate much of modern crime fiction.

Shaw's profession immediately sets him apart. He is a reward seeker, travelling the country tracking down missing persons, fugitives and other hard-to-find individuals in exchange for reward money. Thanks to his unusual upbringing, he possesses an extraordinary skill set that extends beyond simply finding people. He is an expert tracker, highly resourceful, capable of surviving in the wilderness, and adept at reading situations and individuals. It is a concept that feels both original and believable, helping the series stand out in a crowded thriller market.

The novel sees Shaw drawn into the world of computer gaming when a series of kidnappings appears to have connections to an online game. The investigation quickly develops into far more than a routine missing-person case, presenting Shaw with an elusive and dangerous adversary whose actions become increasingly disturbing as the story unfolds.

As readers have come to expect from Deaver, the novel is meticulously constructed. The plot is tightly woven, packed with twists, red herrings and revelations that make it difficult to predict where the story is heading. Deaver has always excelled at creating page-turners and The Never Game is no exception. Once the mystery takes hold, it becomes extremely difficult to put down.

Inevitably, comparisons will be made between Colter Shaw and Lee Child's Jack Reacher. Both are highly capable lone wolves who travel from place to place and frequently find themselves involved in dangerous situations. However, the similarities are largely superficial.

Where Reacher tends to stumble across trouble, Shaw actively pursues cases as part of his profession. He does not wander into conflict through chance encounters in small towns or roadside diners. Instead, he approaches investigations methodically and professionally, more like a traditional detective than an action hero. Shaw's skills are rooted as much in observation and tracking as they are in physical confrontation, which gives the novel a distinctly investigative feel.

This distinction helps make Shaw a compelling protagonist in his own right rather than merely another variation on an established formula. Deaver wisely focuses on the detective aspects of the story, allowing Shaw's intellect and expertise to solve problems rather than relying exclusively on action sequences.

The gaming backdrop is also handled effectively. While technology plays a significant role in the mystery, the novel never becomes bogged down in technical detail. Instead, the gaming world provides an interesting and contemporary framework for the central plot without alienating readers unfamiliar with the subject.

If there is a criticism, it is that some elements of the supporting cast and Shaw's backstory feel as though they are being carefully positioned for future novels rather than fully explored here. However, this is a relatively minor issue in what is otherwise a highly polished thriller.

The Never Game is an excellent introduction to Colter Shaw and a strong start to what would become one of Jeffrey Deaver's most successful series. The reward-seeker concept feels fresh, Shaw is an engaging protagonist, and the plot delivers the twists and suspense that Deaver's readers expect. While comparisons to Jack Reacher are unavoidable, Colter Shaw is very much his own character, operating more as a tracker and detective than a wandering vigilante. An intelligent, compulsive thriller that proves Jeffrey Deaver still knows exactly how to keep readers turning the pages.




Saturday, February 7, 2026

Book Review: The Night Manager John Le Carre * * *


 Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Hotel manager Jonathon Pine is recruited by British secret services to infiltrate the arms dealing operation of Richard Roper to bring him to justice




Review

Who Writes The Night Manager?

John Le Carre was born in 1931 and after attending the universities of Bern and Oxford he taught at Eton and spent five years in the British Foreign Service.  He is best known for his spy novels featuring George Smiley including the novels the Spy Who Cam in From the Cold and Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy.

What is The Night Manager About?

The Night Manager stands apart from much of John le Carré's work. This is not another George Smiley novel concerned with the ideological chess match of the Cold War. Instead, it is a standalone thriller centred on Jonathan Pine, a luxury hotel manager who is recruited by British intelligence to infiltrate the world of international arms dealer Richard Roper.

On paper, the novel sounds like one of le Carré's most accessible premises. We have an ordinary man drawn into espionage, a charismatic villain, undercover operations and a mission to take down a major criminal figure. Yet The Night Manager is also proof that a compelling plot does not always result in a compelling novel.

The book's biggest strength is undoubtedly its subject matter. Le Carré moves espionage into the post-Cold War world, showing how intelligence services have adapted to modern threats. Gone are the ideological battles between East and West that defined the George Smiley novels. In their place are international criminals, arms dealers, financial interests and murky alliances. It is a fascinating look at how espionage changed after the Cold War ended, and in many ways the novel feels like le Carré updating his craft for a new era.

Jonathan Pine is also an interesting protagonist. Unlike the professional spies who populate many espionage novels, Pine begins as an outsider looking in. His motivations are believable, and readers gain a strong understanding of how he becomes involved in the operation against Roper. The character work is, as one would expect from le Carré, extremely detailed and thoughtful.

Unfortunately, this is also where many of the book's problems emerge.

Le Carré's intellectual and introspective writing style works brilliantly in novels such as Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, where the intricate plotting and psychological depth complement the slow-burn narrative. In The Night Manager, however, that same approach often feels excessive. The central thriller plot frequently gets buried beneath pages of character observations, reflections and digressions.

The result is a novel that is far more interested in what its characters think than what they actually do.

This would be less of an issue if the story itself moved at a brisk pace, but The Night Manager is not an action thriller in any conventional sense. Readers expecting a fast-moving tale of espionage and intrigue may be surprised by just how long-winded the narrative can become. Entire sections feel as though they distract from the main story rather than advancing it.

At times, the novel can feel almost chaotic. Events unfold in a way that is not always easy to follow, and there are moments when the narrative resembles a collection of interconnected thoughts and observations rather than a tightly focused thriller. Le Carré writes beautifully, but beauty alone does not always compensate for a lack of narrative economy.

This is perhaps the book's greatest weakness. Much of what is here is worthwhile, but there is simply too much of it. The novel could have benefited from tighter editing and greater concision. In striving to explore every aspect of its characters and their motivations, it sometimes loses sight of the story it is trying to tell.

Yet despite these criticisms, there is still much to admire. The world-building is excellent, Richard Roper is a compelling antagonist, and the examination of modern espionage remains fascinating. Le Carré understands people better than almost any writer in the genre, and that understanding shines through even when the plot meanders.

The Night Manager is an ambitious espionage novel that successfully brings John le Carré's world into the post-Cold War era. Its exploration of modern intelligence work, international crime and the motivations of Jonathan Pine is often insightful and compelling. However, the novel's tendency towards excessive introspection and long-winded storytelling prevents it from achieving the focus and clarity of le Carré's best work. A thought-provoking read for fans of literary espionage fiction, but one that could have benefited from being considerably shorter and more tightly constructed.




Tuesday, February 3, 2026

Book Review: The Devil and the Dark Water Stuart Turton * * *


 Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

It's 1634 and Samuel Pipps, the world's greatest detective, is being transported from the Dutch East Indies to Amsterdam, where he is facing trial and execution for a crime he may, or may not, have committed. Travelling with him is his loyal bodyguard, Arent Hayes, who is determined to prove his friend innocent, while also on board are Sara Wessel, a noble woman with a secret, and her husband, the governor general of Batavia. But no sooner is their ship out to sea than devilry begins to blight the voyage. A strange symbol appears on the sail. A dead leper stalks the decks.

Review

Who Writes The Devil and The Dark Water?

Stuart Turton is your friendly neighbourhood author, responsible for The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle, The Devil and the Dark Water, and The Last Murder at the End of the World - which he describes as the 'not a trilogy' trilogy. His books have appeared on the Sunday Times and USA Today bestseller lists, and are known for fusing locked-room mysteries with literary fiction, sci-fi, fantasy, and horror. Stuart's books have been translated into forty languages and have sold over a million copies, which would be impressive if every author wasn't boasting about exactly the same thing.

What is The Devil and The Dark Water About?

Stuart Turton's The Devil and the Dark Water is often marketed as a crime novel, but readers approaching it as a straightforward detective story may come away disappointed. It certainly contains many of the ingredients associated with crime fiction: a detective, a series of mysterious deaths, a confined setting and a puzzle at its heart. Yet the novel's interests lie elsewhere, and it ultimately feels far more like a piece of atmospheric historical fiction than a traditional mystery.

Set aboard a Dutch trading ship in 1634, the novel initially appears to offer a fascinating historical mystery. However, the historical setting often feels more decorative than essential. Beyond the costumes, ships and period details, relatively little of the plot depends upon the specific era in which the story takes place. The seventeenth century provides atmosphere rather than driving the narrative itself.

Perhaps the biggest surprise is the role of the detective. One of the book's central figures is the renowned investigator Samuel Pipps, yet for much of the novel he is imprisoned and unable to actively participate in the investigation. Readers expecting a brilliant detective methodically unravelling clues may be frustrated by how little actual detection takes place. There is a clever twist behind this choice, but it nevertheless leaves the book feeling oddly disconnected from its supposed detective story foundations.

What Turton is really interested in is atmosphere. The ship becomes a floating world of paranoia, fear and superstition. Rumours spread of a demonic presence stalking the vessel, and much of the story revolves around questions of faith, fear and the supernatural. The result is a novel rich in mood and tension, even if the central mystery occasionally takes a back seat.

This creates something of an identity crisis. The book clearly wants to be a crime novel, but the mystery elements often feel secondary to the atmosphere and character interactions. Readers looking for a tightly plotted detective story may find themselves waiting for a level of investigation that never fully arrives.

The cast of characters reinforces this impression. The novel is packed with larger-than-life figures and familiar historical-fiction archetypes. There are tales of monsters and supernatural forces, eccentric personalities, and characters who seem designed to enrich the atmosphere rather than advance the mystery. The infamous Leper, who is said to haunt the ship, looms over much of the narrative, while a colourful supporting cast adds to the sense of an enclosed world descending into panic.

Because of this, The Devil and the Dark Water often feels closer in spirit to epic historical fiction than to classic detective fiction. Readers who enjoy becoming immersed in a vividly realised setting and spending time with a cast of unusual characters will likely find much to admire. Those coming to it in search of the next great locked-room mystery may feel somewhat short-changed.

That is not to say the novel is poorly written. Turton is highly skilled at creating tension and atmosphere, and the ship itself becomes an unforgettable setting. The problem is more one of expectations. The book is far more successful as an atmospheric historical adventure than it is as a conventional crime novel.

The Devil and the Dark Water is an ambitious and atmospheric novel that blends historical fiction, supernatural horror and mystery elements into something unusual. While it is frequently billed as crime fiction, the detective story often takes a back seat to mood, character and setting. Readers looking for a richly atmospheric historical novel will find plenty to enjoy, but crime fiction fans may be left wishing for a stronger focus on the mystery itself. It is a fascinating read, just perhaps not the detective novel it is often advertised to be.




Monday, February 2, 2026

TV Series Review: Death In Paradise * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Detectives investigate various murders on the Caribbean island of Saint Marie.



Review

What is Death In Paradise About?

Just how original is Death in Paradise? In a television landscape crowded with police procedurals and gritty detective dramas, it manages to stand out by doing something surprisingly old-fashioned. Rather than relying on serialised storylines or dark psychological themes, each episode presents viewers with a carefully constructed mystery, often resembling the classic locked-room puzzles of writers such as John Dickson Carr.

The beautiful Caribbean island of Saint Marie may look like paradise, but it is arguably one of the most dangerous places on television. Week after week, another resident, tourist or expatriate meets an untimely end in circumstances that seem impossible to explain. Fortunately, there is always a sharp-minded detective on hand to untangle the clues and reveal how the crime was committed.

In many ways, Death in Paradise is reminiscent of Midsomer Murders. Both are set in idyllic locations that conceal an improbably high murder rate, and both rely on intricate mysteries rather than violence or action to hold the audience's attention. Saint Marie may offer sunshine, beaches and stunning scenery, but if television is to be believed, it is a distinctly hazardous place to live.

One of the series' greatest strengths is its commitment to the puzzle. Every episode challenges viewers to work out not only who committed the crime, but often how it was physically possible. The solutions are usually clever, logical and satisfyingly explained, making the show particularly appealing to fans of traditional detective fiction.

What is perhaps most remarkable is how the series has maintained its quality despite its longevity. Fourteen seasons in, it continues to entertain and attract viewers. Normally, repeated cast changes would threaten the success of a show built around a central detective. Yet Death in Paradise has handled the departure of its lead characters remarkably well.

Beginning with Ben Miller's DI Richard Poole, the series has introduced a succession of detectives, each bringing a different personality and style to Saint Marie. Instead of weakening the show, these changes have helped keep it fresh. The format is strong enough that new detectives can step into the role while still allowing the series to retain its identity.

The show's popularity has extended far beyond the original series. It has spawned multiple spin-offs, including Beyond Paradise, which follows former detective Humphrey Goodman in rural England, and Return to Paradise, which successfully translates the formula to Australia. The fact that the concept works in such different settings is a testament to the strength of the original idea.

Ultimately, Death in Paradise succeeds because it understands exactly what crime-fiction fans enjoy. Clever mysteries, engaging characters, beautiful locations and a refusal to become overly dark have ensured its enduring popularity. It may not be realistic, but it is endlessly entertaining.

A wonderfully inventive detective series that combines classic locked-room mysteries with Caribbean sunshine and charm. Even after fourteen seasons and numerous cast changes, Death in Paradise remains one of the most consistently enjoyable crime dramas on television.

TV Series Review: Silent Witness * * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * * out of stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

A team of forensic scientists assist the police in solving crimes



Review

Who Writes Silent Witness?

Silent Witness was broadcast on the BBC network in the United Kingdom.  

What is Silent Witness About?

It is hard to believe now, but Silent Witness was one of the first major crime dramas to place forensic science at the centre of its storytelling. Long before CSI turned forensic investigation into a global television phenomenon, Silent Witness was already showing audiences how pathology and scientific evidence could be used to solve crimes.

The series originally revolved around Dr Sam Ryan, played by Amanda Burton, a forensic pathologist who assisted police investigations through her analysis of victims and evidence. In those early years, the programme was relatively focused, combining traditional detective elements with a level of forensic detail that was unusual for television at the time.

Over the decades, however, Silent Witness has undergone a remarkable transformation. Few long-running dramas have changed quite so much while retaining the same title. The departure of Sam Ryan after the eighth series was perhaps the single biggest turning point, ushering in the era of Nikki Alexander, played by Emilia Fox. Now, more than twenty years later, Fox's Nikki has become the defining face of the series for an entire generation of viewers.

What makes Silent Witness particularly unusual is that the cast rotates constantly. Apart from the pathologists themselves, few characters remain for long. Police officers, victims, suspects and supporting characters frequently come and go, meaning the show lacks the stable ensemble cast that many crime dramas rely upon. In theory, this should make it difficult for viewers to remain invested.

There are other factors working against it too. The episodes are often feature-length affairs, some storylines can feel unnecessarily drawn out, and the acting is not always consistently strong. At times, the programme can become rather labourious and self-important.

Yet despite all this, Silent Witness remains one of the BBC's most watched and enduring dramas. There is something about the format that continues to engage viewers. The combination of forensic investigation, complex mysteries and self-contained stories ensures that the series remains highly watchable even after nearly three decades on screen.

Comparing the first series with the most recent is almost like comparing two entirely different programmes. The darker, more procedural style of the early years has gradually evolved into something closer to a medical-crime thriller, with larger casts, more action and increasingly ambitious storylines. The Silent Witness of Series 29 is almost unrecognisable from the Silent Witness of Series 1.

Remarkably, the show's constant reinvention has not damaged its popularity. Instead, it has allowed the series to evolve with its audience and survive long after many of its contemporaries disappeared from television schedules.

Ultimately, Silent Witness is a testament to the strength of its core concept. While almost everything around it has changed, the fascination of using forensic science to uncover the truth remains as compelling today as it was when Sam Ryan first stepped into the mortuary.

A pioneering forensic crime drama that helped popularise the genre long before CSI. Despite dramatic cast changes and a format that has evolved almost beyond recognition, Silent Witness remains one of British television's most enduring and watchable crime series.

TV Series Review: The Glades * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

Chicago cop Jim Longworth relocates to Florida hoping for an easy life but soon begins investigating murders in his new town




Review

What is The Glades About?

At the heart of The Glades is Detective Jim Longworth, a Chicago homicide detective whose life takes an unexpected turn when he is shot by his boss and subsequently relocates to Florida. Expecting sunshine, golf courses and a much easier workload than the streets of Chicago, Longworth soon discovers that murder seems just as common in paradise as it is back home.

The series is clearly trying to embrace the fish-out-of-water formula. Longworth arrives in Florida as an outsider, bringing a very different perspective and style of policing to his new surroundings. There is a light comedic edge to much of the show, particularly as he adapts to the slower pace and unique culture of Florida life. However, the comedy does not always land, and the series is often more successful as a straightforward police procedural than as a crime comedy.

What keeps the show afloat is Jim Longworth himself. Matt Passmore gives the character enough charm, confidence and wit to make him an engaging lead. Longworth is laid-back and unconventional, often appearing more interested in enjoying life than in throwing himself into work. Yet beneath the easy-going exterior lies a sharp detective who invariably gets results.

Without Longworth, it is difficult to imagine the series being particularly memorable. The cases themselves are largely standard procedural fare. Most episodes revolve around fairly conventional murders, and there are few mysteries that genuinely stand out from the vast number of similar crime dramas that populate television schedules.

The series also follows a familiar template in its personal relationships, particularly its ongoing romantic storyline. There is no overarching villain or long-running conspiracy driving the narrative. Instead, viewers are treated to self-contained investigations punctuated by developments in Longworth's personal life.

That is not necessarily a criticism. The Glades knows exactly what sort of show it wants to be and rarely strays from that formula. It is comfortable, easy viewing rather than groundbreaking television. The attractive Florida setting adds a pleasant backdrop, and the chemistry between the recurring characters helps maintain interest even when individual cases are less compelling.

Ultimately, The Glades is a solid but unremarkable police procedural. It lacks the originality and complexity of the very best crime dramas, but its likeable lead and relaxed atmosphere make it an enjoyable way to spend an hour.

A pleasant and watchable crime drama that succeeds largely because of its charismatic lead character. While the mysteries are fairly routine and the comedy is hit-and-miss, Jim Longworth's charm and the Florida setting make The Glades an enjoyable, if not particularly memorable, police procedural.