Wednesday, March 25, 2026

Book Review: And The Corpse Wore Tartan Stuart Macbride (Steel and Tufty 2) * * *


 Star Rating * * * out of 5 stars 

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

The great and the not-so-good are gathered at Skirivour Castle Hotel, in the heart of the Highlands, for the wedding of the year – but they weren’t expecting Detective Sergeant Roberta Steel to crash their party. And get horribly, horribly drunk.  The whole valley’s been cut off by a massive thunderstorm and the phone lines are down, so when the father-of-the-bride’s body is discovered – decoratively impaled on a stag’s head in the hotel lobby – it’s up to DS Steel to find out whodunit. 


Review

Who Writes And The Corpse Wore Tartan?

Stuart MacBride is the Sunday Times No.1 bestselling author of the Logan McRae and Ash Henderson novels. He’s also published standalones, novellas, short stories.

What Is And The Corpse Wore Tartan About?

And The Corpse Wore Tartan is the second entry in Stuart MacBride's Steel and Tufty series, although readers expecting another full-length novel may be surprised to discover that it is much closer to a novella than one of MacBride's typically doorstop-sized crime epics. At a fraction of the length of his usual work, it makes for a very different reading experience, but an enjoyable one nonetheless.

This outing is also notable for being the first in the series to focus entirely on DS Roberta Steel, with no sign of her canine sidekick Tufty. Fortunately, Steel is more than capable of carrying a story on her own. One of MacBride's most entertaining creations, she is in fine form throughout, charging through the investigation with her trademark mix of bullying confidence, sharp tongue and sheer force of personality. As ever, she is frequently abrasive, often politically incorrect, and endlessly entertaining.

What makes the novella particularly interesting is MacBride's decision to pay homage to the Golden Age mystery. Rather than his usual blend of gritty police work and black humour, And The Corpse Wore Tartan deliberately evokes the spirit of Agatha Christie. The setup would be instantly familiar to fans of Miss Marple or Hercule Poirot: a country house, a gathering of suspicious guests and a murder that could have been committed by almost anyone present. The influence is worn proudly on the book's sleeve.

Yet while the structure may be classic Christie, the execution is unmistakably modern and unmistakably Scottish. MacBride infuses every page with Scottish humour, attitudes and observations. The setting never feels like a generic country-house mystery transplanted north of the border. Instead, Scottishness permeates the entire novella, from the dialogue and character interactions to the social observations and sense of place. It feels like a Golden Age mystery filtered through a contemporary Scottish crime-fiction lens.

The book's greatest weakness is simply its length. MacBride's novels are famously substantial affairs, often sprawling investigations filled with numerous plot threads, colourful supporting characters and plenty of dark humour. By comparison, And The Corpse Wore Tartan feels over almost as soon as it begins. While the mystery is satisfying enough, there is an unavoidable sense that readers are getting only a small taste of what MacBride normally delivers. At times it feels as though the premise might have benefited from another hundred pages or so to fully develop its characters and plot.

That said, the novella's brevity also gives it a lightness and pace that suits the Christie-inspired story. It never outstays its welcome, moving briskly from clue to clue before arriving at its solution.

And The Corpse Wore Tartan is a charming and highly entertaining detour for Stuart MacBride. Its affectionate nods to the Golden Age mystery tradition, combined with Roberta Steel's larger-than-life personality and a distinctly Scottish flavour, make it a memorable addition to the series. It may leave readers wishing for more pages, but what is here is great fun, and proof that MacBride can turn his hand to a classic country-house mystery without losing his unique voice.




Saturday, March 21, 2026

TV Series Review: Body of Proof * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

Medical examiner Dr Megan Hunt works with the police to solve crimes


Review

What is Body Of Proof About?

When CSI arrived at the turn of the millennium, it did more than become a successful television series. It reinvented the crime drama, placing forensic science at the forefront of criminal investigations and inspiring countless imitators. Ironically, CSI became so dominant that for years few networks seemed willing to challenge it directly. By the time Body of Proof arrived in 2011, forensic crime drama had become a difficult niche to enter.

Rather than attempting to outdo CSI at its own game, Body of Proof wisely takes a different approach.

The series centres on Dr Megan Hunt, a former neurosurgeon turned medical examiner whose expertise allows her to uncover clues hidden within the bodies of murder victims. Like many television crime-solving professionals, Hunt is brilliant, driven and difficult to work with, but Dana Delany's performance gives the character enough warmth and humour to make her engaging rather than merely abrasive.

What immediately distinguishes Body of Proof from CSI is its treatment of forensic science. While CSI often revelled in cutting-edge technology, elaborate visual effects and highly technical forensic procedures, Body of Proof is considerably less reliant on scientific spectacle. It simply did not have the enormous budget that made CSI famous, and rather than trying to compete directly, it places greater emphasis on character and investigation.

In many respects, the show feels closer to Britain's Silent Witness than to CSI. Although there is no formal connection between the two series, there is a similar emphasis on the medical examiner as a key participant in solving crimes rather than forensic science itself acting as the star attraction. Indeed, there are times when Body of Proof almost feels like an American cousin to Silent Witness, focusing on how pathology contributes to investigations rather than overwhelming viewers with technological jargon.

As a result, the series often functions more as a traditional police procedural that happens to feature forensic specialists. The detectives still do much of the heavy lifting, and the investigations rely upon witness interviews, detective work and conventional policing alongside the medical evidence.

One of the strengths of the show is that it uses its forensic elements realistically. The production employed technical advisers to help ensure accuracy, and the forensic details generally support the story rather than becoming sensationalised. The science never feels as though it is being used purely as a gimmick.

The supporting cast also helps keep the series engaging. While Megan Hunt is undoubtedly the focus, the interactions between the medical examiner's office and the police provide much of the show's appeal. The balance between character drama and crime-solving is generally well judged.

If there is a weakness, it is that Body of Proof never quite develops the distinctive identity needed to stand alongside the very best crime dramas of its era. It is consistently entertaining, but it rarely feels revolutionary. It exists comfortably between the forensic-heavy approach of CSI and the character-driven style of Silent Witness without ever completely eclipsing either.

Body of Proof is a strong forensic crime drama that wisely avoids trying to imitate CSI too closely. By focusing on character, traditional investigation and realistic forensic work, it carves out its own place within the genre. Dana Delany is excellent as Dr Megan Hunt, and the series strikes an effective balance between pathology and police procedure. It may not have reinvented the forensic crime drama, but it proved there was still plenty of life left in the genre after CSI had dominated television for so long.

TV Series Review: Young Sherlock * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * *

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

As a 19-year-old at Oxford University, Sherlock Holmes is not yet the master detective he grows up to be. He is raw and unfiltered, and he lacks discipline. A murder at Oxford puts Holmes's freedom at risk, and he sets out to solve his first murder mystery that leads him to a global-level conspiracy


Review

What is Young Sherlock About?

Following the hugely influential performances of Benedict Cumberbatch in Sherlock and Jonny Lee Miller in Elementary, it is difficult to imagine another television series attempting a straightforward adaptation of Arthur Conan Doyle's detective in the near future. Those portrayals defined Sherlock Holmes for an entire generation of television viewers. As a result, broadcasters looking to tap into the enduring popularity of the character have been forced to approach the legend from new angles.

Young Sherlock is Amazon's latest contribution to the ever-expanding Sherlock Holmes canon, and it takes perhaps the most obvious route: it explores Holmes before he becomes the world's greatest detective.

Nominally, the series is based on Andrew Lane's Young Sherlock Holmes novels. However, anyone familiar with those books may find that claim somewhat puzzling. Beyond a handful of names and broad concepts, there is very little connection between the source material and the television adaptation. In Lane's novels, Sherlock is fourteen years old, not nineteen, and the plot of the first book bears little resemblance to the story depicted on screen.

The relationship between Sherlock and Moriarty is perhaps the most obvious departure. In the novels, there is nothing resembling the friendship portrayed in the series. Of course, anyone familiar with Sherlock Holmes lore knows that such a relationship is destined to end badly. The interest comes from watching how the series intends to transform friends into bitter enemies.

One suspects that the connection to the books has more to do with adaptation rights than creative fidelity. Viewed independently of the novels, however, the series works remarkably well.

A major factor in that success is the involvement of Guy Ritchie. Having previously directed the Robert Downey Jr. Sherlock Holmes films, Ritchie is no stranger to the detective. Interestingly, Young Sherlock often feels more like a pure Guy Ritchie production than either of those films.

The series embraces many of the stylistic elements associated with Ritchie's work. There are fast-paced action sequences, colourful supporting characters and a distinctive energy that occasionally recalls his East End gangster films. In fact, there are moments when the series feels less like a traditional Sherlock Holmes story and more like a Guy Ritchie adventure that happens to feature Sherlock Holmes.

This proves to be one of the show's greatest strengths. The action is frequent and well executed, giving the series an excitement that distinguishes it from more cerebral Holmes adaptations. At the same time, the younger Sherlock is still learning his craft. He is intelligent, observant and capable, but he is not yet the master detective audiences know from later stories.

That makes for an intriguing character study. Watching Sherlock make mistakes, act emotionally and occasionally allow personal matters to cloud his judgement gives the series a different dynamic from most Holmes adaptations. When the central case becomes deeply personal, the character's vulnerabilities become particularly interesting.

The result is a series that succeeds on its own merits, even if its connection to Andrew Lane's novels feels tenuous at best. It may disappoint readers expecting a faithful adaptation, but as an action-packed reimagining of a young Sherlock Holmes, it is highly entertaining.

Young Sherlock is an energetic and enjoyable addition to the Sherlock Holmes universe. While it bears only a passing resemblance to the Andrew Lane novels it supposedly adapts, it benefits enormously from Guy Ritchie's stylish direction and a fresh take on a younger, less polished Sherlock Holmes. Full of action, intrigue and character development, it offers a fascinating glimpse at the detective before he became a legend. The mystery is compelling, but the real attraction is watching Sherlock grow into the man he will eventually become.


Book Review: His and Hers Alice Feeney * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

When a woman is murdered in Blackdown village, newsreader Anna Andrews is reluctant to cover the case. Anna’s ex-husband, DCI Jack Harper, is suspicious of her involvement, until he becomes a suspect in his own murder investigation.



Review

Who Writes His and Hers?

 Alice Feeney is the New York Times and Sunday Times multi-million-copy bestselling author of novels including HIS & HERS, SOMETIMES I LIE, ROCK PAPER SCISSORS, DAISY DARKER, BEAUTIFUL UGLY and MY HUSBAND'S WIFE. Her books have been translated into forty languages, and have been optioned for major screen adaptations. HIS & HERS was an instant Global #1 Netflix show in 2026, starring Tessa Thompson and Jon Bernthal.

What Is His and Hers About?

Alice Feeney's His & Hers is a tightly plotted and highly effective psychological thriller that demonstrates exactly why she has become one of the leading names in the genre. Cleverly structured and full of misdirection, it is the sort of novel that constantly keeps readers guessing while steadily building towards a genuinely shocking conclusion.

The novel is told from three distinct perspectives. The "His" chapters follow DCI Jack Harper, who finds himself in the unenviable position of becoming a suspect in his own murder investigation due to his connection with the victim. The "Hers" chapters focus on Anna Andrews, a television newsreader and Jack's ex-wife, who also has links to the victim. Completing the picture are chapters told from the perspective of the killer, adding an extra layer of intrigue and suspense throughout the story.

This multiple-perspective approach works exceptionally well. Feeney skilfully reveals information piece by piece, allowing readers to see different sides of the same events while never fully understanding what is really going on. Every character seems to have secrets, every revelation creates new questions, and suspects emerge and disappear throughout the novel.

One of the book's greatest strengths is its pacing. This is very much a psychological thriller that builds gradually rather than relying on constant action. The tension steadily increases as the various viewpoints begin to overlap and contradictions emerge. Feeney has a remarkable ability to make readers question everything they think they know.

The mystery itself is superbly constructed. Just when you think you have identified the culprit, another possibility presents itself. The result is a novel where certainty is almost impossible, ensuring that the reader remains engaged from beginning to end.

What truly elevates His & Hers, however, is its ending. Psychological thrillers live or die by their final twist, and Feeney delivers one of the most effective twists in recent crime fiction. It is surprising without feeling unfair, shocking without being ridiculous, and completely redefines much of what came before. Even experienced thriller readers are unlikely to see it coming.

Another advantage is the book's relatively short length. Feeney wastes very little time, keeping the story focused and ensuring there are no unnecessary diversions. The novel can be read quickly, but it is time very well spent.

Ultimately, His & Hers is a masterclass in psychological suspense. Through skilful plotting, compelling characters and a memorable ending, Alice Feeney creates a thriller that is both addictive and deeply satisfying.

A brilliantly constructed psychological thriller packed with suspense, misdirection and one of the best twists in modern crime fiction. Fast-paced, intelligent and impossible to put down, His & Hers is Alice Feeney at her very best.




Friday, March 13, 2026

Book Review: The Alienist Caleb Carr (Dr Laslo Kreizler 1) * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

New York City, 1896. Hypocrisy in high places is rife, police corruption commonplace, and a brutal killer is terrorising young male prostitutes.  Forensics and psychological profiling are still in their infancy, but as the body count rises, Police Commissioner Theodore Roosevelt calls on eminent psychologist or 'alienist', Dr Laszlo Kreizler and crime reporter John Schuyler Moore to trial these new methods.  Kreizler, Moore and their team must venture to the darkest corners of New York - and the human mind - to catch the sadistic killer before they strike again.


Review

Who Writes The Alienist?

Caleb Carr is American novelist and military historian. He has worked at the Council on Foreign Relations, Foreign Affairs Quarterly, MHQ: The Quarterly Journal of Military History, and taught military history, including World Military History, the History of American Intelligence, and Insurgency/Counterinsurgency, at Bard College.  He was born in Manhattan, and for the majority of his life he lived on the Lower East Side of that city, spending his summers and many weekends at his family's home in Cherry Plain, New York. In 2000, he purchased his own property, known as Misery Mountain, in Cherry Plain; and in 2006 he moved there permanently.

What Is The Alienist About?

The Alienist is the first novel in Caleb Carr's Dr Laszlo Kreizler series and remains one of the most ambitious historical crime novels of recent decades. Set in New York at the end of the nineteenth century, the novel follows Kreizler and a small team of investigators as they attempt to hunt down a serial killer using what were then revolutionary ideas about criminal psychology and forensic science.

From the very first pages, it is evident that Carr has thoroughly researched the period. The novel is steeped in the history of New York, and hardly a chapter passes without references to the city's geography, social conditions, politics or prominent historical figures. The period detail is extensive and often fascinating. Readers gain a vivid picture of New York at a time when enormous wealth existed alongside poverty, crime and corruption.

Indeed, the city itself almost becomes a character. The Alienist feels inseparable from its setting, and it is difficult to imagine the story working nearly as well anywhere else. Carr successfully captures the sights, sounds and attitudes of turn-of-the-century New York, giving the novel a distinct historical flavour that lingers long after the final page.

The central investigation revolves around the early development of criminal profiling and forensic techniques. In many ways, this is Criminal Minds before Criminal Minds existed. Dr Kreizler and his colleagues attempt to understand the psychology of the killer, while also using scientific methods that were still viewed with considerable scepticism by law enforcement and society at large. This aspect of the novel is genuinely intriguing and remains one of its greatest strengths.

Unfortunately, the plot sometimes becomes overshadowed by the sheer weight of the historical detail. While the setting is impressively realised, there are periods where the investigation loses momentum and becomes difficult to follow. At times, the novel appears more interested in demonstrating its historical research than advancing the story, which can make sections feel unnecessarily slow.

This issue is compounded by the book's length. At well over 500 pages, The Alienist often feels significantly longer than it needs to be. There is undoubtedly an excellent thriller buried within its pages, but it could probably have reached the same destination with two hundred fewer pages. There are stretches where the narrative drags and where readers may find their attention wandering away from the mystery itself.

That said, the novel remains an impressive achievement. The combination of historical fiction, serial-killer investigation and early forensic science creates something distinctive and memorable. Even when the pacing falters, the originality of the concept and the richness of the setting keep the reader engaged.

Ultimately, The Alienist is a novel that is easier to admire than to love. Its research is impeccable, its setting superbly realised and its central premise fascinating. Yet its excessive length prevents it from being the gripping thriller it might otherwise have been.

A fascinating blend of historical fiction and psychological crime novel that vividly recreates nineteenth-century New York. While the pioneering forensic themes and rich historical setting are compelling, the story often gets lost beneath the weight of its research, resulting in a novel that feels considerably longer than it needed to be.