Saturday, January 31, 2026

Book Review: Clive Cussler's Desolation Code Graham Brown (Numa Files 21) * * *


 Star Rating * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

When NUMA’s Kurt Austin and Joe Zavala investigate a mass whale stranding in the Indian Ocean, they uncover a heap of trouble.  First, their findings are stolen – someone doesn’t want them examining those dead whales. But who, and why?  Next, Kurt and Joe are chasing a mysterious beacon that might provide some answers. That’s if their global satellite network hasn’t been hacked – which increasingly seems the case.  Soon, Kurt, Joel and a heavily compromised NUMA are racing to stop a plan to devastate the world’s ecosystems – the first step in a terrifying scheme to re-make all life on Earth . . .


Review

Who Writes Desolation Code?

Clive Cussler remains one of the greatest adventure writers.  He has developed numerous adventure series including the well known Dirk Pitt adventures and the Isaac Bell Adventures.  The Numa Files are the fourth series he developed and follows the adventures of Kurt Austin and his sidekick Joe Zavala as they work for National Underwater and Marine Association (NUMA) undertaking various projects which often get them into trouble.  Graham Brown is the author of several of his own works and has co authored a number of Cussler's works before Cussler's passing in 2020 and now writes the NUMA files continuation novels officially authorised by the Cussler estate

.What is Desolation Code About?

The themes explored in Desolation Code are not entirely new to readers of the NUMA Files series, but Clive Cussler and Graham Brown manage to give them a distinctive twist. This is very much a techno-thriller, combining action, conspiracy and emerging technology in a way that will feel familiar to fans of writers such as Dan Brown, albeit with a stronger emphasis on adventure and science.

The story sees Kurt Austin and Joe Zavala investigating a mysterious organisation led by a figure known only as the Overseer. As the novel progresses, the true purpose of this shadowy group gradually emerges, revealing an alarming vision of humanity's future and raising questions about technology, control and the direction of modern society.

The conspiracy element is one of the book's greatest strengths. The authors slowly uncover the organisation's motives, ensuring that the mystery remains compelling throughout. While some of the themes may be familiar to seasoned thriller readers, the way they are woven into the plot keeps the story engaging.

Kurt Austin continues to be an appealing protagonist. He is perhaps not quite the larger-than-life all-American hero that Dirk Pitt was in Cussler's most famous series, but he remains an effective and likeable lead. Austin possesses the intelligence, courage and determination needed to confront the increasingly dangerous situations he encounters, even if he often feels a little more grounded than his iconic predecessor.

As with most NUMA Files novels, the pacing is brisk. The action scenes arrive at regular intervals, helping to maintain momentum and ensuring that the story never lingers too long on exposition. Readers looking for a fast-moving thriller will find plenty to enjoy here.

What gives Desolation Code an extra layer of interest is its exploration of the relationship between humans and technology. While the ideas presented are not always deeply examined, they are thought-provoking enough to elevate the novel beyond a straightforward action adventure. The vision of a future where the boundaries between people and technology become increasingly blurred is one of the more intriguing aspects of the story.

The novel is also highly accessible. It is an easy and entertaining read that moves quickly from one set piece to another without becoming overly complicated. Readers are never required to wrestle with complex scientific explanations or dense technical detail, making it ideal holiday reading or a straightforward thriller for those looking to escape for a few hours.

Ultimately, Desolation Code delivers exactly what fans of the NUMA Files series have come to expect: a blend of action, mystery, technology and adventure wrapped up in a highly readable package. It may not be the most original thriller ever written, but it succeeds as an entertaining and fast-paced adventure.

A compelling techno-thriller with an intriguing conspiracy at its heart. While some of its themes are familiar, Desolation Code remains an enjoyable and thought-provoking adventure that combines action and technology in classic NUMA Files fashion.





Thursday, January 29, 2026

TV Series Review: Mademoiselle Holmes * * *


 Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: France

Synopsis

Following a car accident the great grand daughter of Sherlock Holmes gains his powers of deduction and crime solving skills




Review

What is Mademoiselle Holmes About?

It was probably inevitable. After years of British and American television repeatedly reinventing Sherlock Holmes for new audiences, the French have now joined the Holmes revival with Mademoiselle Holmes, a light-hearted crime drama that gives the world's greatest detective a distinctly French twist.

The premise is delightfully absurd. Somehow, Sherlock Holmes has acquired a French branch of the family tree, and his great-granddaughter Charlie Holmes is working in a relatively modest role within the French police. Following a car accident, however, she suddenly develops extraordinary powers of observation and deduction, discovering that she has inherited some of her famous ancestor's talents. Before long, she finds herself helping to solve murders and impressing those around her with her newfound abilities.

The series' greatest strength is that it never seems overly concerned with whether this premise makes the slightest bit of sense. Instead, it embraces the idea with enthusiasm and a healthy sense of humour. Much of the fun comes from seeing just how the writers have managed to weave Sherlock Holmes into a contemporary French police procedural. The Holmes references are constant, with nods to Arthur Conan Doyle's creation appearing throughout the series.

In truth, though, the Sherlock Holmes angle is more of a hook than the engine that drives the show. While Charlie possesses heightened observational skills, the cases themselves are generally straightforward murder mysteries rather than intricate puzzles requiring the sort of brilliant deductions associated with Baker Street's famous resident. Viewers expecting locked-room mysteries, fiendishly complex conspiracies or elaborate intellectual battles may be disappointed. Most episodes unfold as fairly conventional procedural investigations.

That is not necessarily a criticism. Mademoiselle Holmes works perfectly well as an accessible crime comedy with a strong central gimmick. The murder investigations are entertaining, the characters are likable, and the tone remains light throughout. Unlike some modern crime dramas, the series is rarely interested in becoming excessively dark or self-important. There is a playful energy running through the show that makes it consistently watchable.

The French setting also helps give the series its own identity. While the Holmes connection may attract viewers initially, it is the charm of the characters and the easy-going procedural format that keeps them watching. Charlie Holmes is an engaging lead, even if her detective abilities never quite reach the level her surname might suggest.

Ultimately, Mademoiselle Holmes succeeds because it understands exactly what it is. Rather than attempting to create a definitive new interpretation of Sherlock Holmes, it uses the famous detective as a launching point for a cheerful and entertaining crime series. The Holmes mythology remains ever-present, even when it is not especially central to solving the week's mystery.

Mademoiselle Holmes is an enjoyable crime comedy that cleverly capitalises on the enduring appeal of Sherlock Holmes while charting its own path. The procedural mysteries are fairly standard, and the Holmes connection often feels more cosmetic than essential, but the series' charm, humour and willingness not to take itself too seriously make it an entertaining addition to the ever-growing family of Holmes-inspired adaptations.


TV Series Review: Leverage: Redemption * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

A group of con artists with specialist skills take down criminals and pull cons to help the needy



Review

What is Leverage Redemption About?

Dean Devlin clearly never gave up on Leverage. Despite the original series ending after five successful seasons, the concept remained popular enough to justify a revival, and Leverage: Redemption finds a new home while bringing most of the beloved team back together for another round of cons, scams and elaborate takedowns.

The premise remains largely unchanged. Once again, a group of criminals, hackers, grifters and thieves use their unique skills to help ordinary people who have been wronged by the rich and powerful. Fans of the original series will immediately recognise the familiar formula, with each episode centring around a carefully orchestrated con designed to expose corruption and deliver a measure of justice.

One significant change is the absence of Timothy Hutton's Nate Ford. Whether through circumstance or creative choice, the mastermind of the original series is no longer present. In his place, Gina Bellman's Sophie Devereaux steps into a more prominent leadership role. Bellman performs admirably, and Sophie is more than capable of carrying the team, but the dynamic inevitably feels different without Nate's often morally ambiguous guidance.

The rest of the gang are largely back to their old tricks, and there is undeniable pleasure in seeing familiar characters reunited. The chemistry that made the original series so watchable is still present, at least in flashes, and longtime fans will find much to enjoy simply through spending time with these characters again.

Where Leverage: Redemption struggles is in its attempt to be bigger, louder and more contemporary than the original. The new series frequently feels as though it is trying a little too hard. Some of the cons become overly complicated or strained, stretching credibility further than the original ever did. The balance between cleverness and fun that Leverage usually managed so effortlessly is occasionally lost.

This also affects the team dynamic. One of the great strengths of the original series was how natural everything felt. The characters worked together with an easy familiarity that developed over years. In Redemption, there are moments when the interactions feel more forced, as though the show is consciously trying to recreate what came naturally the first time around.

It is perhaps inevitable that comparisons will be made with the original. Leverage itself owed more than a little to the British series Hustle, which similarly centred around a team of con artists pulling elaborate scams. Like Hustle, the original Leverage succeeded because of its charm, humour and ensemble cast as much as its plots.

Leverage: Redemption retains many of those qualities but never quite recaptures the magic. It remains entertaining and perfectly watchable, particularly for fans of the original, but it often feels like a good imitation of what once was a great show.

A welcome return for a beloved team of con artists, but one that struggles to match the effortless charm and chemistry of the original series. While there is still fun to be had watching the crew take down villains, Leverage: Redemption often feels as though it is trying a little too hard to recreate past glories.

TV Series Review: White Collar * * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Con man Neal Caffrey begins working with the FBI investigating white collar crimes as part of his plea deal



Review

What is White Collar About?

How refreshing it is to watch a crime drama where somebody does not get murdered every single episode. As much as crime fiction fans enjoy a good whodunnit and trying to solve the killer's identity before the detectives do, there is something wonderfully different about White Collar. This is a series that proves crime drama can be just as engaging when it focuses on fraud, forgery, art theft and scams rather than an endless procession of bodies.

At the heart of the series is Neal Caffrey, one of television's most charismatic criminals. Neal is a con artist, forger and occasional international thief who embodies the image of the perfect gentleman. Sophisticated, intelligent and charming, he is equally at home discussing Renaissance paintings, rare wines, priceless antiques or counterfeit currency. His talents are extraordinary, even if they have often been applied on the wrong side of the law.

The series begins after Neal engineers a prison escape just months before the end of his sentence. Once recaptured, he strikes an unusual deal with the FBI, agreeing to help solve white-collar crimes in exchange for his freedom. The reasons behind his escape become one of the show's major ongoing storylines and provide much of the emotional drive in the early seasons.

What follows is one of the most enjoyable partnerships in modern television crime drama. Neal works alongside FBI agent Peter Burke, creating a classic odd-couple dynamic. Peter represents law and order; Neal represents flexibility, creativity and occasionally bending the rules when necessary. Their friendship develops naturally over the course of the series and becomes one of its greatest strengths.

Because of the show's focus on white-collar crime, viewers are treated to cases involving forged masterpieces, stolen artefacts, financial scams, confidence tricks and elaborate cons. Rather than venturing into the darkest corners of crime, White Collar spends much of its time exploring the world of the super-rich and the crimes that accompany great wealth. It is a world of exclusive galleries, auction houses, collectors and international intrigue.

The supporting cast is equally strong, but one character stands above the rest: Mozzie. Neal's eccentric friend, occasional accomplice and conspiracy theorist is one of television's most memorable sidekicks. Distrustful of authority and deeply suspicious of almost everyone, Mozzie provides much of the show's humour while also proving surprisingly capable whenever Neal needs help. The friendship between Neal and Mozzie is genuinely touching, and many of the series' best moments involve the pair working one of their schemes.

What makes White Collar so appealing is its tone. The show is clever without becoming self-important, dramatic without becoming bleak and humorous without turning into a comedy. It understands that audiences are watching to spend time with characters they enjoy rather than simply solve the week's crime.

White Collar is one of the most charming and entertaining crime dramas of its era. By focusing on fraud, forgery and high-end theft rather than murder, it carves out a unique identity in a crowded genre. Matt Bomer's charismatic performance as Neal Caffrey, combined with the excellent supporting cast and the unforgettable Mozzie, makes for consistently enjoyable television. Stylish, witty and endlessly watchable, White Collar proves that crime drama does not need a body count to be compelling.

Wednesday, January 28, 2026

Book Review: The Scene of the Crime Linda La Plante (Jessica Russell 1) * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

The husband of a prominent and infamously ruthless barrister is found in horrific condition after a robbery and brutal assault. Now in a coma, a major investigation is launched using the newly formed, experimental Metropolitan Police Serious Crime Analysis Unit.  Jessica Russell is an experienced CSI with degrees in psychology and criminology with an exceptional Masters in Investigative psychology and behaviour analysis. But Jessica's first job as team leader of MSCAN is entirely new to her: to bring together a team of three trusted officers.

Review

Who Write The Scene of the Crime?

Lynda La Plante was born in Liverpool. She is the author of over forty novels, all of which have been bestsellers. She trained for the stage at RADA and worked with the National theatre and RSC before becoming a television actress. She then turned to writing - and made her breakthrough with the phenomenally successful TV series Widows.  Lynda's original script for the much-acclaimed Prime Suspect won awards from BAFTA, Emmys, British Broadcasting and Royal Television Society as well as the 1993 Edgar Allan Poe Award.

What is The Scene Of The Crime About?

With The Scene of the Crime, Lynda La Plante moves into new territory. Having achieved enormous success with Prime Suspect and its accompanying novels, she was already well established as one of Britain's leading crime writers. However, this novel marks the beginning of a new series and introduces an entirely different perspective on criminal investigations.

Rather than centring the story on a police detective, La Plante focuses on the world of forensic science. It is a choice that clearly reflects the influence of television hits such as CSI and Silent Witness, both of which had demonstrated that audiences were just as interested in how crimes were solved scientifically as they were in the detectives chasing suspects.

The novel introduces the Metropolitan Police's newly formed MSCAN unit, a specialist department designed to provide forensic and crime scene investigation services across London. At its head is Jessica Russell, a highly qualified Crime Scene Investigator tasked with building and leading the new organisation.

This shift in focus immediately distinguishes the novel from many police procedurals. The investigation is viewed primarily through a forensic lens, and La Plante devotes considerable attention to the practical applications of forensic science. Readers are given detailed insight into how evidence is recovered, analysed and interpreted, as well as how forensic findings support and complement traditional detective work. Those who enjoy the procedural side of crime fiction will find much to appreciate here, as La Plante clearly relishes exploring the methods and techniques that underpin modern investigations.

Jessica Russell is also an effective protagonist. As with many crime fiction leads, she is damaged, driven and deeply committed to her career. Yet what is refreshing is that La Plante does not force her into situations where she does not naturally belong. Unlike some forensic investigators in television dramas who end up conducting interviews, interrogating suspects and effectively becoming detectives in all but name, Jessica remains firmly within the boundaries of her role. She appears when her expertise is needed and contributes to the investigation in a way that feels both realistic and credible.

This restraint strengthens both the character and the story. Jessica's professional competence is enough to make her interesting without requiring her to dominate every aspect of the narrative. As a result, the novel feels grounded in the realities of forensic investigation rather than becoming another detective story wearing a CSI disguise.

La Plante's experience in crime storytelling is evident throughout. The pacing is strong, the procedural detail is convincing, and there is a genuine fascination with the science behind criminal investigations. While the emphasis on forensics may not appeal to readers looking for a more action-driven thriller, those interested in the mechanics of modern policing will find the approach rewarding.

The Scene of the Crime is a successful and refreshing departure for Lynda La Plante. By focusing on forensic investigation rather than traditional detective work, she creates a crime novel that feels distinct from her Prime Suspect books while retaining the procedural authenticity that has always been one of her strengths. Jessica Russell proves an engaging lead, and the detailed exploration of forensic science makes for an absorbing and convincing police procedural.




Monday, January 26, 2026

TV Series Review: Cooper and Fry * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

DC Ben Cooper begins working with DC Diane Fry investigating various crimes in the Peak District


Review

What is Cooper and Fry About?

Adapting a long-running and much-loved crime fiction series is never easy, but Cooper & Fry does an admirable job of bringing Stephen Booth's Peak District mysteries to the screen. Drawing its stories from the author's novels, with each episode adapting one of the books rather than following their original publication order, the series captures much of what made the source material such a distinctive part of British crime fiction.

The show's greatest success is its evocation of the Peak District itself. As in Booth's novels, this is not simply a picturesque backdrop for a murder investigation. The landscape feels ancient, mysterious and often slightly unsettling. The series embraces the books' unique blend of police procedural and local folklore, creating a setting where modern crime sits alongside centuries-old legends. Tales of the infamous Black Dog and other local myths are woven naturally into the stories, giving the series an atmosphere that feels richer and more distinctive than the average detective drama.

Just as important is the relationship between detectives Ben Cooper and Diane Fry. Many television crime dramas try to generate warmth and easy camaraderie between their leads, but Cooper & Fry stays faithful to the novels by presenting a partnership that is often difficult, abrasive and occasionally uncomfortable. Cooper's deep roots in the local community frequently clash with Fry's more sceptical and detached outlook. Their relationship is built on professional necessity rather than friendship, and the series wisely resists the temptation to soften these edges. The resulting tension provides much of the drama's emotional core.

The adaptation also captures the gruff northern character that permeates Booth's books. The dialogue, attitudes and communities feel authentically rooted in their setting, avoiding the polished, metropolitan feel that sometimes affects British crime dramas. There is a quiet toughness to both the people and the landscape, reflecting the novels' view of the Peak District as a place where history and hardship leave lasting marks.

Beyond these strengths, Cooper & Fry remains largely a conventional police procedural. The investigations unfold in familiar fashion, with interviews, forensic evidence and steady detective work guiding the plot towards a resolution. Viewers looking for radical innovation may not find it here, but the series' faithfulness to the books' atmosphere and character dynamics helps elevate it above many of its peers.

What ultimately distinguishes Cooper & Fry from countless other detective dramas is its sense of place. The combination of bleak moorland landscapes, local folklore and the prickly relationship between its two leads gives the series a personality all its own. Like the novels that inspired it, it understands that the mystery is only part of the story; the landscape, the history and the people are equally important.

Cooper & Fry is a faithful adaptation that successfully captures the atmosphere, mythology and character conflicts that made Stephen Booth's novels so popular. While the investigative plots follow a fairly standard procedural formula, the haunting Peak District setting and the frequently strained partnership between Ben Cooper and Diane Fry ensure that the series stands out in a crowded field of British crime dramas.


Sunday, January 25, 2026

Book Review: The Killing Stones Anne Cleeves (Jimmy Perez and Willow Reeves 1) * * * *

 


Star Rating * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

When a violent storm descends on Orkney the body of Archie Stout is left in its wake.  An unusual weapon, an ancient neoltihic stone bearing ancient inscriptions is found nearby.




Review

Who Writes The Killing Stones?

Ann is the author of the books behind ITV's VERA, now in it's third series, and the BBC's SHETLAND, which will be aired in December 2012. Ann's DI Vera Stanhope series of books is set in Northumberland and features the well loved detective along with her partner Joe Ashworth. Ann's Shetland series bring us DI Jimmy Perez, investigating in the mysterious, dark, and beautiful Shetland Islands...

What Is The Killing Stones About?

Eighteen years after Jimmy Perez last appeared in Wild Fire, Ann Cleeves finally brings one of crime fiction's most beloved detectives back to the page. Remarkably, The Killing Stones does not make a great fuss about his return. There are no dramatic reintroductions or attempts to remind readers why they liked him in the first place. Instead, it feels as though Cleeves has simply picked up where she left off.

Much has changed in Perez's life, however. No longer based in Shetland, he is now learning the rhythms of Orkney and adjusting to life with his partner, Willow Reeves, who also happens to be his boss. Yet despite the change in scenery, Perez remains recognisably the same thoughtful, empathetic detective readers came to admire throughout the original series.

As fans of Ann Cleeves will expect, the setting is every bit as important as the crime itself. Just as the Shetland novels drew heavily on the landscapes, history and culture of the islands, The Killing Stones intertwines its mystery with the mythology, archaeology and ancient history of Orkney. The result is a novel that could not really be set anywhere else. It quickly becomes apparent that Orkney may prove just as dangerous a place to live as Shetland.

One of the novel's greatest strengths is Cleeves's ability to create character through conversation. It is rare for dialogue to carry so much weight in a crime novel, but here it becomes one of the primary storytelling tools. People reveal themselves not through dramatic action but through the things they say, the things they avoid saying and the subtle ways they interact with one another. This gives the novel an authenticity that many modern thrillers lack.

The familiar themes of island life are also present throughout. Cleeves once again explores the sometimes uneasy relationship between locals and incomers, the strength of community ties and the resilience required to live in remote places. These social dynamics are just as important to the story as the investigation itself and help give the novel its distinctive atmosphere.

Unlike many modern crime novels that rely heavily on action or shocking twists, The Killing Stones is a slow-burning mystery. The investigation unfolds naturally through observation, conversation and careful detective work. When the identity of the killer is finally revealed, it feels both surprising and believable. The solution comes somewhat out of left field and is unlikely to be guessed by most readers, yet Cleeves ensures that all the necessary clues have been there from the start.

Ultimately, The Killing Stones is a welcome return for Jimmy Perez and proof that Ann Cleeves has lost none of her ability to create compelling mysteries rooted in place and character. Rather than reinventing Perez, she simply allows him to continue doing what he does best: quietly uncovering the truth hidden beneath the surface of a close-knit community.

A superb return for Jimmy Perez that successfully transports the series from Shetland to Orkney without losing any of its appeal. Rich in atmosphere, character and local history, The Killing Stones demonstrates once again why Ann Cleeves remains one of Britain's finest crime writers.





Friday, January 23, 2026

Book Review: The Distant Echo Val McDermid (Karen Pirie 1) * * *


 Star Rating * * * out of stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

In 1978 Rosie McDuff is found murdered by four friends who quickly become suspects.  In 2003 the case remains unsolved and just as the Police launch a cold case review the four friends start dying in mysterious circumstances.



Review

Who Writes The Distant Echo?


Val McDermid is a number one bestseller whose novels have been translated into more than forty languages, and have sold over eighteen million copies. She has won many awards internationally, including the CWA Gold Dagger for best crime novel of the year and the LA Times Book of the Year Award. She was inducted into the ITV3 Crime Thriller Awards Hall of Fame in 2009, was the recipient of the CWA Cartier Diamond Dagger in 2010 and received the Lambda Literary Foundation Pioneer Award in 2011. 

What Is The Distant Echo About?

When Val McDermid wrote The Distant Echo, it is difficult to believe she had a long-running series in mind for Karen Pirie. Although the novel is now regarded as the first book in the Karen Pirie series, Pirie barely features in the story. When she does appear, she is more of a supporting figure than the driving force behind the narrative. This is very much a novel about the people connected to the crime rather than the detective investigating it.

The story begins in 1978 when four university students discover the body of barmaid Rosie Duff. Their unfortunate proximity to the murder quickly makes them suspects, and although they are never charged, the shadow of the crime hangs over them for decades. Rather than focusing solely on solving the murder, McDermid is more interested in exploring the long-term consequences of suspicion and how a single traumatic event can shape lives.

This character-driven approach is both the novel's greatest strength and its greatest weakness. The four friends dominate the narrative, and much of the story is devoted to examining how they have changed since that fateful day. Their friendships, careers, relationships and personal failures are all influenced by their connection to Rosie's murder. McDermid handles this aspect very well, creating believable characters whose lives feel authentic and often tragic.

The opening section of the novel, set in 1978, is particularly detailed and occupies a significant portion of the book. The depiction of student life, the social atmosphere of the period and the immediate aftermath of the murder are all convincingly rendered. However, there are times when the novel feels more interested in these historical sections than in the modern-day investigation.

This perhaps creates the impression that there is less material available once the narrative returns to the present. The cold-case investigation develops steadily enough, but it rarely feels as compelling as the earlier character-driven sections. For readers expecting a fast-moving crime novel, the pace may occasionally feel sluggish.

Another issue is that the identity of the killer is not especially difficult to work out. Experienced crime-fiction readers may well form a strong suspicion long before the final pages. McDermid keeps the official confirmation until the closing chapters, but the mystery itself is arguably less important than the emotional impact the crime has had on those involved.

Fortunately, McDermid's writing is strong enough to carry the story even when the mystery element is less successful. She excels at exploring guilt, memory and the way communities respond to tragedy. The novel often feels less like a whodunnit and more like a study of lives damaged by crime.

Ultimately, The Distant Echo is an interesting and somewhat unusual entry in the crime-fiction genre. Readers approaching it as the first Karen Pirie novel may be surprised by how little Pirie actually appears. Those willing to embrace it as a story about the lasting consequences of an unsolved murder, however, will find much to admire.

A thoughtful and character-focused crime novel that places the impact of murder above the mystery itself. While the solution is relatively easy to anticipate and Karen Pirie plays only a minor role, Val McDermid's exploration of friendship, suspicion and the passage of time makes The Distant Echo a compelling read.




Thursday, January 22, 2026

TV Series Review: Wild Cards * * *


 Star Rating * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: Canada

Synopsis

Con woman Max Mitchell begins working with the police after she solves a crime for them


Review

What is Wild Cards About?

The idea of a con artist helping the police solve crimes is hardly a new one. Television audiences have seen similar concepts before, perhaps most notably in White Collar, which arguably handled the premise with greater sophistication. Nevertheless, Wild Cards manages to put its own spin on the formula and does enough differently to justify its existence.

The series pairs demoted detective Cole Ellis with professional con woman Max Mitchell, creating the kind of mismatched partnership that crime television has relied upon for decades. The key difference is that Max's criminal background is not merely a gimmick. Her skills as a grifter and manipulator are woven effectively into the investigations, with many cases requiring her ability to deceive suspects, infiltrate situations and think outside conventional police methods.

This integration of the con-artist element is one of the show's strongest features. Rather than feeling bolted on, Max's talents are essential to solving the week's mystery, giving the series a clear identity beyond that of a standard procedural.

Like many modern crime dramas, Wild Cards also includes several storylines that run across the entire season. Both Cole Ellis and Max Mitchell have personal mysteries and ongoing character arcs that develop gradually in the background. Thankfully, these longer stories rarely overwhelm the episodic cases and usually complement rather than distract from the main focus of the show.

The series has all the ingredients of a successful buddy-cop drama. The central partnership is engaging, the cases are entertaining and the performances are consistently strong. Yet there remains a feeling that something is stopping the show from becoming genuinely excellent.

It is difficult to pinpoint exactly what that missing ingredient is. The writing is solid, the cast are likeable and the format works well. However, the series never quite reaches the level of the very best crime dramas. It lacks that extra spark that transforms a good procedural into essential viewing.

Perhaps this is because Wild Cards deliberately avoids extremes. It is not a dark, gritty thriller filled with tortured detectives and grim realism, nor is it a full-blown comedy. Instead, it comfortably inhabits the space between the two, offering light, entertaining mysteries without demanding too much from the viewer.

And there is nothing wrong with that. Not every crime drama needs to be groundbreaking. Sometimes an enjoyable hour spent with appealing characters and a well-constructed mystery is enough.

Ultimately, Wild Cards is an easy and entertaining watch that makes good use of its central premise. While it may never challenge the genre's heavyweights, it provides enough charm and energy to make it worth sticking with.

A fun and well-acted crime drama that puts a fresh spin on the con artist and detective partnership. While it falls short of greatness and lacks the depth of the genre's best examples, Wild Cards is consistently entertaining and makes for enjoyable, undemanding viewing.

TV Series Review: Instinct * * *


 Star Rating * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

Professor Reinhart begins working with the NYPD after a serial killer uses his book as clues to a case



Review

Who Writes Instinct?

Instinct aired on the CBS network in the United States

What is Instinct About?

Of all the James Patterson novels that could have been adapted for television, Murder Games seems an unusual choice. Unlike the Alex Cross novels or the Women's Murder Club books, it was not the foundation of a major series. By the time Instinct arrived on CBS, Women's Murder Club had already been cancelled, and the later Cross television series was still years away. Yet somehow it was Murder Games that got the television treatment.

What makes Instinct particularly interesting is that, for once, an American network actually made a genuine attempt to use Patterson's source material. The first episode is based on Murder Games itself, albeit in a heavily compressed form. Given the constraints of a forty-five-minute television slot, much of the novel's complexity inevitably disappears, but the broad outline remains recognisable. After that opening episode, however, the series largely abandons the books and heads into original territory.

The resulting show is a very typical American crime drama. At its core is a buddy-cop partnership, with crimes solved through a combination of police work, profiling and the occasional flash of insight from its unconventional consultant. It is a formula that television audiences have seen many times before, and Instinct rarely strays far from it.

The most distinctive aspect of the series is its lead character. Alan Cumming plays Professor Dylan Reinhart, a former CIA operative turned academic whose expertise is called upon to assist the police. Notably, Reinhart is openly gay, making him one of the few lead characters in a mainstream network crime procedural to occupy that role. This was not something invented for television. The series deserves credit for retaining an important aspect of the character from Patterson's novel, along with much of his backstory.

Alan Cumming is, unsurprisingly, the show's greatest asset. He brings charisma, intelligence and a sense of fun to Reinhart that helps elevate material that often feels conventional. Without him, the series would likely have struggled to distinguish itself from the countless other procedural dramas competing for viewers' attention.

Watching Instinct, it is difficult not to feel that CBS was looking for its own version of Castle. Both series feature a civilian consultant working alongside a detective, both rely heavily on the chemistry of their central pairing, and both blend crime-solving with lighter character moments. Unfortunately, Instinct never quite captures the spark that made Castle such a success. The cases are serviceable, the characters are likeable enough, but the show lacks the wit, energy and memorable chemistry that allowed Castle to rise above the crowded procedural market.

As a result, Instinct often feels somewhat pedestrian. There is nothing particularly wrong with it, but neither is there much that makes it stand out. The mysteries are enjoyable enough, the performances are solid, and the production values are perfectly respectable. It is simply difficult to identify anything that makes the series essential viewing.

Perhaps that explains why it lasted only two seasons. While it found an audience, it never quite developed the momentum needed to become a long-running hit.

Instinct is a competent and occasionally enjoyable crime procedural that benefits enormously from Alan Cumming's engaging lead performance. Its connection to James Patterson's Murder Games provides an interesting foundation, and the decision to retain the character's original background is commendable. However, after moving beyond the source material, the series settles into familiar procedural territory and never quite achieves the charm or originality of shows such as Castle. Entertaining enough while it lasts, but ultimately a fairly average entry in the crowded world of American crime dramas.

Wednesday, January 21, 2026

TV Series Review: Murder Most Puzzling * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Puzzle lady Cora Felton begins assisting the Bakerbury police when a murderer leaves a puzzle clue on a body.



Review

What is Murder Most Puzzling About?

It is perhaps no surprise that it was the British rather than the Americans who chose to adapt Parnell Hall's Puzzle Lady novels for television. The books have always possessed the kind of cosy charm that fits naturally into Britain's long-standing love affair with amateur sleuths, eccentric villages and light-hearted murder mysteries. While the original novels are distinctly American, Murder Most Puzzling feels perfectly at home alongside the growing wave of British cosy crime dramas.

One of the biggest changes is the setting. Hall's novels take place in the United States, but the television adaptation relocates the action to an idyllic slice of rural Britain. It is an understandable decision. The picturesque villages, quirky locals and gently comic atmosphere are all familiar ingredients to British audiences and help the series fit comfortably into the cosy mystery genre.

Fans of the books will be pleased to discover that the first episode is remarkably faithful to the opening novel. Apart from the transatlantic relocation, the plot follows its source material closely enough that readers are unlikely to encounter many surprises. The adaptation captures the spirit of the book well and demonstrates a genuine affection for Hall's creation.

After that, however, the series largely strikes out on its own. Subsequent episodes move away from the source material and tell original stories. This is not unusual for crime drama adaptations, but it does mean that the show gradually becomes its own entity rather than a straightforward adaptation of the novels.

The cosy mystery influences are visible throughout. Murder Most Puzzling clearly knows its target audience and embraces the genre's conventions wholeheartedly. There are eccentric characters, picturesque settings, witty exchanges and mysteries that prioritise entertainment over gritty realism. At times, it feels as though the series is trying to position itself alongside modern cosy mystery successes such as The Thursday Murder Club, capitalising on the current popularity of gentler crime fiction.

The problem is that it does not always pull this off successfully. The tone occasionally feels uncertain, and some episodes struggle to balance humour, mystery and character development. While the series is undeniably charming, it sometimes lacks the confidence and sharpness needed to elevate it into the top tier of cosy crime dramas.

That said, the show remains highly watchable. The central premise is appealing, the mysteries are entertaining enough, and the overall atmosphere is warm and inviting. It succeeds as comfort viewing, which is often exactly what audiences are looking for from this type of programme.

Murder Most Puzzling is an enjoyable adaptation that successfully transports Parnell Hall's American sleuth into a distinctly British setting. The first episode remains impressively faithful to the source novel, while later episodes carve out their own path. Although it never quite matches the best examples of the modern cosy mystery boom, it delivers enough charm, intrigue and eccentricity to make for pleasant viewing. Fans of gentle, puzzle-driven crime dramas should find plenty to enjoy.

TV Series Review: High Potential * * *

 


Star Rating * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

Morgan Gillory, and intellectually gifted cleaning woman, begins working with the LAPD after she helps to solve a crime

Review

What s High Potential About?

American network television has struggled somewhat in the crime-drama genre in recent years. The great wave of procedural hits from the late 1990s and 2000s has largely faded away, with only a handful of long-running franchises such as NCIS remaining from that golden era. Against that backdrop, High Potential feels like something of a return to form and one of the more promising crime dramas to emerge from the major American networks in quite some time.

The series has a genuinely strong hook. At its centre is Morgan Gillory, a woman with an exceptional intellect whose remarkable ability to spot patterns and connections allows her to solve crimes that leave trained detectives baffled. It is a premise that immediately gives the show an identity and helps it stand out in a crowded genre.

There is, however, one caveat. High Potential is not an original creation. It is an American remake of the hugely successful French-Belgian series HPI. That said, most viewers outside Europe are unlikely to be familiar with the original, meaning the concept still feels fresh and distinctive.

The notion of a civilian with extraordinary intellectual abilities helping the police is not entirely unprecedented. One could perhaps draw comparisons with Monk or similar detective shows featuring unconventional investigators. Nevertheless, High Potential manages to make the idea feel modern and engaging through both its execution and its central performance.

What works particularly well is that the intellectual aspect never becomes overbearing. The series avoids the trap of turning every episode into a lecture on genius-level thinking or making the protagonist feel superhuman. Instead, Morgan's abilities are integrated naturally into the investigations. Her insights help solve cases, but the mysteries themselves remain the focus. The balance between character and crime is handled well, ensuring that the series remains accessible and entertaining.

The weekly investigations are engaging without becoming overly complicated, and the show wisely maintains a light touch. While there are serious crimes to solve, the tone remains enjoyable and often humorous. This makes High Potential feel more approachable than some of the darker crime dramas currently dominating television.

The cast also contribute significantly to the show's success. The chemistry between the characters helps ground what could otherwise be a rather far-fetched premise, and the police investigations feel believable enough to support Morgan's unique contribution.

Perhaps most importantly, the show feels sustainable. Many modern crime dramas struggle to establish a concept that can carry multiple seasons. High Potential feels like it has found a formula capable of lasting for years, provided the writing remains strong and the character relationships continue to develop.

Ultimately, High Potential succeeds because it takes a familiar procedural format and injects it with an appealingly different lead character. It may be a remake rather than an original creation, but it proves that a good idea can travel remarkably well.

A clever, entertaining and highly watchable crime drama that gives the American procedural genre a much-needed lift. While it owes its existence to the French-Belgian series HPI, High Potential stands comfortably on its own as one of the strongest network crime dramas of recent years.

TV Series Review: Shakespeare and Hathaway Private Investigators * * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Lu Shakespeare begins working with Private Detective Frank Hathaway when she is involved in a crime



Review

What is Shakespeare and Hathaway About?

What happens when you combine Shakespeare, private detectives and a healthy dose of comedy? The result is Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators, one of the most charming and enjoyable cosy crime series to emerge from British television in recent years.

The setting is no accident. Stratford-upon-Avon, the home of William Shakespeare, is woven into the very fabric of the show. References to the Bard, theatre and acting appear throughout the series, giving it a distinctive identity that helps it stand apart from the crowded field of daytime detective dramas. Rather than feeling forced, these literary and theatrical nods are integrated naturally into the stories and the community in which they unfold.

At the centre of the series are private investigators Frank Hathaway and Luella Shakespeare, an unlikely partnership whose contrasting personalities provide much of the show's appeal. Their relationship develops into a warm and entertaining dynamic, helped enormously by the performances of the lead cast. The chemistry between the characters ensures that even when the mysteries themselves are relatively straightforward, the series remains thoroughly enjoyable.

One of the show's greatest strengths is its accessibility. This is not a drama that demands intense concentration or rewards viewers with dark psychological twists. Instead, it embraces its cosy-mystery roots wholeheartedly. The murders and mysteries are engaging without being particularly disturbing, making the show ideal comfort viewing.

The cases generally fit the tone of the series well. They are varied enough to remain interesting, yet never feel out of place within the quirky world that Shakespeare & Hathaway has created. There is a lightness to the storytelling that allows the mysteries to entertain without becoming overly complicated.

The comedy is another key ingredient. While the show never becomes a full-blown sitcom, it consistently finds humour in its situations and characters. Much of this comes from Sebastian Brudenell, the struggling actor who assists the detectives and often steals scenes with his theatrical flair and larger-than-life personality. His involvement helps reinforce the show's affection for the world of acting and performance.

Ultimately, Shakespeare & Hathaway knows exactly what it wants to be. It does not aspire to be a gritty crime drama or a groundbreaking detective series. Instead, it offers warmth, humour, likeable characters and enjoyable mysteries, and it executes that formula remarkably well.

A delightful and highly watchable cosy mystery series that blends crime, comedy and Shakespearean charm. With strong performances, entertaining cases and a wonderfully light-hearted tone, Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators is perfect comfort viewing for fans of traditional detective stories.  

Saturday, January 17, 2026

TV Series Review: Blindspot * * * *


 Star Rating * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United States

Synopsis

A woman is left in Times Square, New York in a bag and covered in tattoos.  The FBI discover they are links to crimes they must solve.

Review

What is Blindspot About?

Blindspot is very much a full-on action crime drama. From its intriguing opening premise to its fast-paced investigations, the series rarely pauses for breath. It combines action, conspiracy and procedural storytelling in a highly entertaining package that makes it an easy and enjoyable watch.

The central concept is a strong one. A mysterious woman is discovered in Times Square, covered head to toe in tattoos and with no memory of who she is. Each tattoo contains clues to future crimes, conspiracies or threats, giving the FBI a new mystery to solve every week while simultaneously building towards a larger overarching story.

As an episodic crime drama, Blindspot works very well. The weekly cases are generally engaging, the action sequences are well staged and the mysteries are cleverly tied into the tattoo concept. The format provides a steady stream of enjoyable stories, making the series easy to binge-watch.

Where the show begins to struggle is with its larger mythology. There is a sense that, unlike The Blacklist, the writers had not fully worked out all the answers when they first came up with the premise. As the series progresses and the truth behind Jane Doe's identity begins to emerge, some of the explanations feel a little forced. The reasons why certain events occur and why characters are connected often give the impression of being retrofitted to the original concept rather than naturally growing from it.

This doesn't completely derail the show, but it does weaken some of the later storylines. The overarching conspiracy never quite reaches the level of intrigue or consistency that the opening premise promises.

Fortunately, Blindspot remains a lot of fun. The cast are likeable, the action is frequent and the pacing rarely allows viewers to dwell too long on the more questionable plot developments. Jaimie Alexander's performance as Jane Doe anchors the series effectively, while the FBI team provides enough chemistry and camaraderie to keep audiences invested.

The comparison with The Blacklist is an obvious one. Both series revolve around a central mystery, a weekly procedural format and a larger conspiracy gradually unfolding in the background. While The Blacklist arguably handles its mythology more effectively, Blindspot delivers enough action and entertainment to satisfy viewers looking for a similar experience.

Ultimately, Blindspot succeeds because it understands that its primary job is to entertain. It may not stand up to close scrutiny, and some of its larger plot twists feel somewhat shoehorned into the narrative, but it remains a highly watchable thriller from start to finish.

A fast-moving and highly entertaining action-crime series with a brilliant central premise. While the overarching conspiracy occasionally feels improvised rather than planned, the strong cast, engaging weekly mysteries and relentless pace make Blindspot an easy recommendation for fans of shows such as The Blacklist.

TV Series Review: Strike * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Follows the work of private detective Coroman Strike and his assistant as they investigate various crimes



Review

Who Writes Strike?

Strike aired on the BBC network in the United Kingdom.  

What is Strike About?

It is remarkable how quickly the Strike novels found their way onto television screens. The BBC clearly recognised the potential of J.K. Rowling's crime-fiction series, written under the pseudonym Robert Galbraith, and moved swiftly to adapt the books. One suspects there was a hope that Strike might capture some of the cultural impact of Rowling's Harry Potter phenomenon, although that level of success was always going to be difficult to replicate.

While the novels may not have become quite the global sensation of Rowling's earlier work, the television adaptation has been a considerable success in its own right. More importantly, it has remained exceptionally faithful to the source material.

Each series is based directly on one of the novels, which means viewers are effectively watching a dramatisation of the books rather than a reinvention. The consequence of this approach is that long gaps between series are inevitable while waiting for new novels to be published. Readers who have already worked their way through the books will also know exactly where the story is heading, as the adaptation rarely strays far from the original plots.

That faithfulness is one of the programme's greatest strengths. Rather than making unnecessary changes, the series focuses on bringing Rowling's characters and stories to life. Tom Burke is superb as Cormoran Strike, capturing both the detective's intelligence and his sometimes abrasive personality. Alongside him, Holliday Grainger is equally impressive as Robin Ellacott, and the growing relationship between the two characters forms the emotional heart of the series.

The chemistry between the leads is crucial, and both actors excel in portraying a partnership that evolves naturally over time. Much of the appeal of the novels comes from Strike and Robin's professional and personal relationship, and the adaptation handles this aspect particularly well.

The cases themselves are also engaging. Unlike many contemporary detective dramas, Strike tends to favour complex investigations and character-driven storytelling over action and spectacle. The mysteries unfold gradually, often requiring patience from the viewer, but the payoff is usually worthwhile.

In terms of tone, the series sits somewhere between traditional detective drama and modern crime thriller. It is certainly not a cosy mystery in the mould of The Marlow Murder Club or Death in Paradise. There is a darkness to many of the stories, and the series is unafraid to tackle serious themes. However, it never becomes relentlessly grim or oppressive in the way some Scandinavian noir dramas can.

Visually, the programme also benefits from its London setting. The city is portrayed as both vibrant and gritty, mirroring the contrast between Strike's often chaotic personal life and the glamorous worlds he is sometimes called upon to investigate.

Ultimately, Strike succeeds because it understands the appeal of its source material. Rather than trying to reinvent the novels, it adapts them with care and respect, resulting in one of the strongest literary crime adaptations of recent years.

A superb adaptation of the Cormoran Strike novels that remains impressively faithful to the books while bringing the characters vividly to life. Strong performances from Tom Burke and Holliday Grainger, combined with intelligent mysteries and a compelling central partnership, make Strike one of the finest detective dramas currently on television.

TV Series Review: Borderline * * *


 Star Rating: * * *out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: Ireland

Synopsis

Members of Northern Irelands Police Service and Irelands Garda begin working together to investigate crimes that occur on the border


Review

What is Border Line About?

It is a testament to the enduring influence of Bron/Broen (The Bridge) that more than a decade after its debut, crime dramas are still drawing inspiration from its central concept. The idea of detectives from different jurisdictions working together across a border has proved remarkably fertile ground for television writers. The Americans, British and Germans have all produced variations on the theme, and Borderline represents Ireland's attempt to explore the complexities of cross-border policing.

Even if the creators had arrived at the concept independently, comparisons with The Bridge were always going to be inevitable. The Scandinavian series was the first to popularise the format and remains the benchmark against which all subsequent border-based crime dramas are measured.

Borderline certainly contains several familiar elements. Most obviously, it features a tough yet troubled female detective in the lead role. Like Saga Norén before her, the central Garda investigator is intended to be fiercely independent, uncompromising and emotionally guarded. However, the execution is not always as successful. Amy De Bhrún gives a committed performance, but there are times when her character comes across as simply rude rather than projecting the complex toughness the writers are aiming for. It is a difficult balance to achieve, and Borderline does not always find it.

Where the series differs from The Bridge is in its structure. Rather than dedicating an entire season to a single sprawling investigation, Borderline tackles several different cases over the course of a season. This gives the show a more conventional procedural feel and helps maintain variety, although it also means that individual investigations sometimes lack the depth and complexity that a season-long mystery can provide.

One of the series' strengths is its willingness to engage with Irish history and identity. The border between Northern Ireland and the Republic is not simply a geographical line but one shaped by decades of political, social and cultural history. The show frequently incorporates these themes into its stories, adding an authenticity that distinguishes it from many other police procedurals. The legacy of the past often looms over the present, giving the series a sense of place and purpose.

The investigations themselves are generally solid without being particularly groundbreaking. The writing is competent, the cases are engaging enough, and the cross-border setting provides opportunities for conflicts and complications that a more routine crime drama might not possess. However, the series rarely reaches the heights of the productions that inspired it.

Ultimately, Borderline is a good example of a crime drama that knows what it wants to be but struggles occasionally to escape the shadow of a much more famous predecessor. It benefits from its Irish setting and historical themes, but it never quite develops the distinctive identity needed to stand alongside the very best of the genre.

Borderline is a solid, if unspectacular, entry into the growing subgenre of cross-border crime dramas. Its exploration of Irish history and its unique setting add depth to the investigations, while the procedural format keeps the stories moving. Comparisons with The Bridge are unavoidable, and the series does not quite match the influence or originality of its Scandinavian inspiration, but it remains an enjoyable and worthwhile crime drama in its own right.

Friday, January 16, 2026

TV Series Review: Patience * * *


 Star Rating: * * * out of stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

An autistic archivist working for the police begins assisting Detectives in solving cases.



Review

Who Writes Patience?

Patience aired on the Channel 4 network in the United Kingdom. 

What is Patience About?

Channel 4 has often lagged behind competitors such as ITV and the BBC when it comes to producing mainstream crime dramas, so there was considerable interest when it announced Patience. On the surface, the series appears to offer a fresh twist on the detective genre, centring on an autistic records clerk whose unique way of thinking helps solve complex criminal cases.

Of course, crime fiction has increasingly embraced neurodivergent characters since the success of series such as The Bridge, which helped normalise autistic and autistic-coded protagonists within mainstream television. As a result, Patience initially appears to be following a well-established trend while giving it a distinctly British flavour.

A closer look reveals that the series is not quite as original as it first seems. Patience is in fact a British adaptation of the successful French-Belgian drama Astrid et Raphaëlle, in which an autistic archivist working for the police becomes involved in criminal investigations. While the premise may not be entirely new, the adaptation does a commendable job of making it work for a British audience.

What immediately stands out is the show's pacing. Patience never feels overly aggressive or sensationalist, yet it also avoids becoming a slow-burning procedural. Instead, it strikes an appealing balance, moving briskly enough to keep viewers engaged without becoming unnecessarily complicated. This makes it an easy and enjoyable watch, particularly for those who prefer character-driven mysteries over convoluted plots.

The series is also helped by its sensitive portrayal of autism. Rather than turning Patience into a superhuman detective or defining her entirely by her condition, the show makes a genuine effort to portray both her strengths and the challenges she faces in everyday life. The inclusion of autistic performers and consultants helps give the series an authenticity that many similar dramas have sometimes lacked.

The cases themselves are entertaining, even if they rarely reinvent the crime-drama genre. Much of the show's appeal comes from the interaction between the characters and the way Patience's perspective helps uncover details others have overlooked. The investigations are engaging without demanding too much concentration, making the series ideal comfort-viewing crime drama.

Perhaps its greatest achievement is that it never feels preachy. The show integrates its themes naturally into the storytelling, allowing viewers to appreciate the characters as people first and foremost.

Ultimately, Patience succeeds because it combines an appealing central character with accessible mysteries and a warm, engaging tone. While it may not be the groundbreaking original that some initially believed it to be, it is nevertheless a strong adaptation that stands comfortably on its own merits.

A thoughtful and highly watchable crime drama that balances engaging mysteries with an authentic portrayal of autism. Despite being adapted from an existing French series, Patience feels fresh, approachable and consistently entertaining.


Book Review: Death Cloud Andrew Lane (Young Sherlock Holmes 1) * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country Of Origin: United States

Synopsis

In 1868 and Sherlock Holmes in fourteen.  When two people die of symptoms that resemble the plague, Holmes begins to investigate and find out what really happened.




Review

Who Writes Death Cloud?

Andrew Lane is an author, journalist and lifelong Sherlock Holmes fan. He lives in Hampshire with his wife and son. Before Moriarty and before Benedict Cumberbatch, Andrew's passion for the original novels of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and his determination to create an authentic teenage Sherlock Holmes made him the perfect choice to reinvent the world’s most famous detective for the Young Sherlock Holmes series.

What Is Death Cloud About?

With Death Cloud, Andrew Lane takes on what might seem like an impossible task: writing a Sherlock Holmes novel when the world's most famous detective has not yet become a detective. Officially authorised by the Conan Doyle Estate, the Young Sherlock Holmes series carries the seal of approval of Holmes' original custodians, and Lane uses that freedom to explore a side of the character that Arthur Conan Doyle never really examined.

What we get is Sherlock before Baker Street, before Dr Watson, and before the deductive genius became world famous. In Death Cloud, Sherlock is still a teenager, and perhaps the most interesting aspect of the novel is watching those famous skills develop. Lane cleverly shows that Holmes is already observant, intelligent and curious, but he is still learning how to apply those talents. This is Sherlock in training rather than Sherlock at his peak.

Naturally, this means the novel is aimed at a younger audience than most Sherlock Holmes pastiches. Sherlock's age mirrors the intended readership, and the result is a book that is highly accessible and easy to read. Younger readers can identify with the protagonist while still enjoying the mystery and adventure elements.

The writing style reflects this target audience. Despite being set in Victorian Britain, Death Cloud does not immerse itself heavily in the language or atmosphere of the period. There are few attempts to recreate Victorian speech patterns or employ historical colloquialisms. Purists might find this disappointing, but it makes the novel far more approachable for modern readers. The story moves quickly and never gets bogged down in historical detail.

As a historical novel, therefore, it is relatively light on atmosphere. Victorian England provides the backdrop, but the setting rarely becomes a major character in the story. Lane's priority is keeping the narrative moving and ensuring that readers remain engaged with Sherlock's adventure.

Fortunately, the plot is strong enough to achieve exactly that. The central mystery involving a deadly disease outbreak provides plenty of intrigue, while the supporting cast introduces several memorable characters who help shape Sherlock's development. The book also does an excellent job of laying the foundations for the detective Holmes will eventually become, showing how his experiences as a teenager contribute to the methods and personality readers know from the original stories.

Perhaps the novel's greatest success is that it feels like Sherlock Holmes without requiring Sherlock to actually be Sherlock Holmes yet. Lane captures the essence of the character while still allowing him room to grow and make mistakes.

Death Cloud is an engaging and accessible introduction to Andrew Lane's Young Sherlock Holmes series. While it places more emphasis on adventure than on recreating the atmosphere of Victorian Britain, it succeeds in presenting a believable young version of Conan Doyle's famous detective. Easy to read, packed with interesting characters and anchored by a compelling mystery, it serves as an entertaining entry point for younger readers and Holmes fans curious to see how the great detective's story might have begun.