Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars
Country of Origin: United Kingdom
Synposis
Antiquarian book seller Gabriel Book aides the police investigating crimes.
Review
Who writes Bookish?
Bookish was written by Marck Gatiss and made in Belgium. It aired on U&Alibi in the UK.
What is Bookish About?
Bookish represents Mark Gatiss's return to crime drama following the enormous success of Sherlock. However, anyone expecting another fast-paced, contemporary mystery filled with dazzling deductions and high-energy storytelling may be in for a surprise.
Set in the years immediately following the Second World War, Bookish is very much a period crime drama. The production does an excellent job of recreating the era, from the costumes and locations to the social attitudes and atmosphere of a Britain still recovering from the effects of war. The historical setting is ever-present and helps give the series a distinctive identity.
The problem is that Bookish is something of a slow burner. The series takes its time developing both its characters and stories, but in doing so it lacks much of the urgency and excitement that characterised Sherlock. Whereas that earlier series grabbed viewers almost immediately, Bookish requires a considerable investment of patience before it begins to reveal its strengths.
One of the more surprising aspects of the show is how little use it makes of its central premise. Given the title and the fact that the protagonist, Gabriel Book, is a book dealer, one might reasonably expect literature, rare books or literary mysteries to feature heavily in the storylines. Instead, books largely exist as part of the character's profession rather than as a meaningful component of the mysteries. Beyond occasional references to people buying or selling books, the literary angle feels underdeveloped.
This feels like a missed opportunity. There is certainly scope for a crime series to make books and literature central to its mysteries, and Bookish rarely explores that possibility.
The crimes themselves are competent enough, but they rarely feel fresh or particularly memorable. The mysteries are serviceable and occasionally intriguing, yet they lack the ingenuity or originality that might have elevated the series above its competitors. The stories do not often leave a lasting impression once the credits roll.
To the show's credit, it avoids falling into the cosy-mystery category. Despite the period setting and intellectual central character, Bookish is often darker and grittier than its premise might suggest. There is a seriousness to the storytelling that distinguishes it from lighter historical detective dramas.
The performances are generally strong, and Gatiss brings his usual intelligence and presence to the production. Yet there remains a feeling throughout that the series never quite capitalises on its most interesting ideas.
Ultimately, Bookish is a respectable and occasionally engaging crime drama, but one that struggles to escape the shadow of its creator's earlier work. The period setting is excellent, and the darker tone is welcome, but the mysteries and premise never quite come together in a truly compelling way.
A well-produced and atmospheric historical crime drama that benefits from its post-war setting and strong performances. However, its slow pace, underused literary premise and largely unremarkable mysteries prevent Bookish from reaching the heights of Mark Gatiss's best work.

No comments:
Post a Comment