Monday, January 12, 2026

TV Series Review: Grace * * *


 Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Follows DI Roy Grace of Sussex Police as he investigates murders in and around the town of Brighton


Review

Who Writes Grace?

Grace was broadcast on the ITV network.

What is Grace About?

It seems remarkable that Peter James's Roy Grace novels took so long to reach the small screen. Given the popularity of the books and the longevity of the series, a television adaptation always felt inevitable. In fact, the journey to the screen was delayed in part by casting considerations, with Hugh Bonneville originally linked to the lead role before other commitments made his involvement impossible.

Instead, the role fell to John Simm, and it is difficult to imagine a better choice. Simm brings exactly the right blend of intelligence, determination and quiet melancholy to Detective Superintendent Roy Grace. He captures a man haunted by his past yet utterly committed to his work, creating a detective who feels both believable and compelling.

One of the most striking aspects of Grace is just how faithful it is to Peter James's novels. Many television adaptations treat source material as little more than inspiration, but Grace remains remarkably loyal to the books. In some places the dialogue and plot developments feel almost lifted directly from the page. As a result, readers familiar with the novels will know exactly where the story is heading and are unlikely to encounter many major surprises.

Fortunately, this faithfulness proves to be one of the series' strengths rather than a weakness. The novels are already tightly constructed police procedurals, and the television adaptation wisely trusts the quality of James's storytelling. The result is a series that feels authentic to fans while remaining accessible to newcomers.

What stands out about both the books and the adaptation is how contemporary the crimes feel. Peter James has always shown a keen interest in modern criminal methods, emerging technologies and the changing nature of policing. The cases deal with distinctly twenty-first-century offences and investigations, making the series feel firmly rooted in the modern world.

Ironically, Roy Grace himself often feels slightly out of step with that world.

There is something old-fashioned about Grace, both in the novels and in John Simm's portrayal. Whether it is his quiet demeanour, his methods, or his fascination with psychic and paranormal insights, he often seems more suited to an earlier era of detective fiction. Surrounded by cutting-edge forensic techniques and modern criminal enterprises, Grace can feel like a detective from another time somehow operating in the present day.

Far from being a flaw, this contrast gives the character much of his appeal. Grace's old-fashioned qualities make him stand out in a television landscape crowded with abrasive antiheroes and deeply dysfunctional detectives. He is troubled, certainly, but he remains fundamentally decent and professional.

The production itself is polished and atmospheric, making excellent use of Brighton as a setting. The city becomes almost a character in its own right, providing both picturesque locations and a suitably dark undercurrent for the investigations.

Grace is one of the most faithful crime-fiction adaptations currently on television, bringing Peter James's bestselling novels to life with remarkable accuracy. John Simm is excellent in the title role, capturing both the intelligence and vulnerability that define Roy Grace. While the modern crimes and investigations feel very contemporary, Grace himself remains appealingly old-fashioned, creating a fascinating contrast that helps the series stand out. Fans of the books will find much to admire, while newcomers are treated to a first-rate British crime drama.

No comments:

Post a Comment