Star Rating * * * out of 5 stars
Country of Origin: United States
Synopsis
Professor Reinhart begins working with the NYPD after a serial killer uses his book as clues to a case
Review
Who Writes Instinct?
Instinct aired on the CBS network in the United States
What is Instinct About?
Of all the James Patterson novels that could have been adapted for television, Murder Games seems an unusual choice. Unlike the Alex Cross novels or the Women's Murder Club books, it was not the foundation of a major series. By the time Instinct arrived on CBS, Women's Murder Club had already been cancelled, and the later Cross television series was still years away. Yet somehow it was Murder Games that got the television treatment.
What makes Instinct particularly interesting is that, for once, an American network actually made a genuine attempt to use Patterson's source material. The first episode is based on Murder Games itself, albeit in a heavily compressed form. Given the constraints of a forty-five-minute television slot, much of the novel's complexity inevitably disappears, but the broad outline remains recognisable. After that opening episode, however, the series largely abandons the books and heads into original territory.
The resulting show is a very typical American crime drama. At its core is a buddy-cop partnership, with crimes solved through a combination of police work, profiling and the occasional flash of insight from its unconventional consultant. It is a formula that television audiences have seen many times before, and Instinct rarely strays far from it.
The most distinctive aspect of the series is its lead character. Alan Cumming plays Professor Dylan Reinhart, a former CIA operative turned academic whose expertise is called upon to assist the police. Notably, Reinhart is openly gay, making him one of the few lead characters in a mainstream network crime procedural to occupy that role. This was not something invented for television. The series deserves credit for retaining an important aspect of the character from Patterson's novel, along with much of his backstory.
Alan Cumming is, unsurprisingly, the show's greatest asset. He brings charisma, intelligence and a sense of fun to Reinhart that helps elevate material that often feels conventional. Without him, the series would likely have struggled to distinguish itself from the countless other procedural dramas competing for viewers' attention.
Watching Instinct, it is difficult not to feel that CBS was looking for its own version of Castle. Both series feature a civilian consultant working alongside a detective, both rely heavily on the chemistry of their central pairing, and both blend crime-solving with lighter character moments. Unfortunately, Instinct never quite captures the spark that made Castle such a success. The cases are serviceable, the characters are likeable enough, but the show lacks the wit, energy and memorable chemistry that allowed Castle to rise above the crowded procedural market.
As a result, Instinct often feels somewhat pedestrian. There is nothing particularly wrong with it, but neither is there much that makes it stand out. The mysteries are enjoyable enough, the performances are solid, and the production values are perfectly respectable. It is simply difficult to identify anything that makes the series essential viewing.
Perhaps that explains why it lasted only two seasons. While it found an audience, it never quite developed the momentum needed to become a long-running hit.
Instinct is a competent and occasionally enjoyable crime procedural that benefits enormously from Alan Cumming's engaging lead performance. Its connection to James Patterson's Murder Games provides an interesting foundation, and the decision to retain the character's original background is commendable. However, after moving beyond the source material, the series settles into familiar procedural territory and never quite achieves the charm or originality of shows such as Castle. Entertaining enough while it lasts, but ultimately a fairly average entry in the crowded world of American crime dramas.

No comments:
Post a Comment