Monday, January 12, 2026

TV Series Review: McDonald and Dodds * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Follows DCI Lauren McDonald and DS Dodds as they investigate crime and murders in the Bath area.




Review

Who Writes McDonald and Dodds?

McDonald and Dodds was broadcast on the ITV network in the United Kingdom.

What is McDonald and Dodds About?

At its heart, McDonald & Dodds is a classic chalk-and-cheese detective drama. The entire series is built around the contrast between its two lead investigators, and while this formula is hardly new, the show does enough with it to keep things fresh and entertaining.

DCI Lauren McDonald arrives in Bath from the Metropolitan Police and immediately embodies the image of the modern, ambitious detective. She is confident, career-driven, and likes things done by the book. Her approach to policing is direct and professional, and she often struggles to understand why anyone would do things differently.

Set against her is DS Dodds, a shy, retiring detective who seems almost invisible at first glance. He lacks McDonald's confidence, dislikes confrontation, and rarely commands attention in the way television detectives usually do. Yet it is Dodds' quirky way of looking at the world that often unlocks the mysteries. While McDonald tackles investigations through conventional police work, Dodds notices the details that everyone else has overlooked.

The dynamic between the two is undoubtedly the show's main attraction, although it does not always work perfectly. At times McDonald's treatment of Dodds can be frustrating, and viewers are likely to find themselves sympathising far more with him than with his superior officer. Jason Watkins in particular brings a warmth and vulnerability to Dodds that makes him immediately likeable.

What really helps McDonald & Dodds stand out, however, is the nature of its mysteries. While it remains a police procedural at heart, the crimes are often more imaginative than those found in many detective dramas. The series delights in presenting unusual puzzles that require genuine thought to solve. Cases such as a victim mysteriously disappearing from a hot-air balloon during flight move the show closer to the tradition of puzzle mysteries than standard police procedurals.

These cases are not quite locked-room mysteries in the classic Agatha Christie or John Dickson Carr sense, but they share some of the same appeal. The emphasis is often less on gritty realism and more on presenting an intriguing conundrum that demands an ingenious solution.

The setting of Bath also contributes greatly to the series' charm. The elegant streets and historic architecture provide an attractive backdrop, reinforcing the show's slightly quirky and old-fashioned sensibilities. It feels like a world where unusual crimes and eccentric suspects naturally belong.

Ultimately, McDonald & Dodds succeeds because it embraces its own individuality. The mysteries are quirky, the lead detective partnership is quirky, and even the pacing feels a little different from most contemporary crime dramas. Not every aspect of the central relationship works all the time, but the clever mysteries and Dodds' endearing personality more than compensate.

McDonald & Dodds is an enjoyable detective drama that combines an unconventional detective partnership with mysteries that are far more inventive than the average police procedural. The contrast between the driven Lauren McDonald and the understated DS Dodds provides the show's emotional core, while the clever, often unusual crimes give viewers genuine puzzles to solve. Quirky crimes for a quirky duo, and all the better for it.


No comments:

Post a Comment