Star Rating: * * out of 5 stars
Country Of Origin: United Kingdom
Synposis
Follows DI Thorne as he investigates various murders.
Review
What is Thorne About?
Adapting Mark Billingham's bestselling Tom Thorne novels for television should have been a recipe for success. The books are popular, the central character is well established, and the stories possess the dark edge that has fuelled much of British crime fiction over the last two decades. Yet while Thorne is a perfectly competent crime drama, it never quite manages to capture everything that makes the novels so compelling.
To its credit, the series remains fairly faithful to Billingham's source material. The major plot points survive intact, and there are only relatively minor changes to the characters and storylines. Fans of the books will recognise much of what unfolds on screen, and there is a clear effort to respect the original novels rather than radically reinvent them.
The problem is that faithfulness alone does not necessarily make for great television.
One of the defining features of Billingham's books is their slightly chaotic nature. Tom Thorne is not a polished television detective. The novels often feel messy in a deliberate way, with flawed characters, awkward relationships and investigations that rarely proceed smoothly. The television adaptation captures some of this atmosphere, but only partially. Much of the rough-edged energy that drives the novels seems to have been smoothed out in the transition to the screen.
What emerges instead is a fairly standard police drama. The investigations are engaging enough, but they lack some of the depth and personality found in the books. The series never feels bad exactly, but neither does it feel particularly memorable.
This is one of those rare cases where it is easier to identify that something is missing than to explain precisely what it is. The performances are perfectly serviceable. The cast does a solid job with the material and nobody appears miscast. The production values are equally respectable, and the plots are strong enough because they originate from successful novels.
And yet the series never truly comes alive.
Perhaps the issue is simply that Billingham's strengths as a writer do not translate easily to television. Much of what makes the novels work lies in Thorne's personality, his observations, and the atmosphere Billingham creates on the page. These qualities can be difficult to recreate visually. The result is an adaptation that captures the events of the books more effectively than it captures their spirit.
That is not to say Thorne is without merit. Viewed as a straightforward British crime procedural, it is perfectly watchable. The mysteries are solid, the pacing is steady, and there is enough intrigue to hold the viewer's attention. It simply struggles to distinguish itself in a crowded television landscape filled with detective dramas.
Thorne is a faithful and competent adaptation of Mark Billingham's novels, but it ultimately serves as a reminder that some books work better on the page than on the screen. While the cast and production are perfectly adequate, the series never quite captures the distinctive atmosphere and chaotic energy of the novels. Enjoyable enough for fans of British crime drama, but one of the few occasions where the books are unquestionably the superior experience.

A thoughtful review — Thorne sounds like a solid, faithful British crime drama, and the point about the books losing something on screen rings very true.
ReplyDelete