Tuesday, February 3, 2026

Book Review: The Devil and the Dark Water Stuart Turton * * *


 Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

It's 1634 and Samuel Pipps, the world's greatest detective, is being transported from the Dutch East Indies to Amsterdam, where he is facing trial and execution for a crime he may, or may not, have committed. Travelling with him is his loyal bodyguard, Arent Hayes, who is determined to prove his friend innocent, while also on board are Sara Wessel, a noble woman with a secret, and her husband, the governor general of Batavia. But no sooner is their ship out to sea than devilry begins to blight the voyage. A strange symbol appears on the sail. A dead leper stalks the decks.

Review

Who Writes The Devil and The Dark Water?

Stuart Turton is your friendly neighbourhood author, responsible for The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle, The Devil and the Dark Water, and The Last Murder at the End of the World - which he describes as the 'not a trilogy' trilogy. His books have appeared on the Sunday Times and USA Today bestseller lists, and are known for fusing locked-room mysteries with literary fiction, sci-fi, fantasy, and horror. Stuart's books have been translated into forty languages and have sold over a million copies, which would be impressive if every author wasn't boasting about exactly the same thing.

What is The Devil and The Dark Water About?

Stuart Turton's The Devil and the Dark Water is often marketed as a crime novel, but readers approaching it as a straightforward detective story may come away disappointed. It certainly contains many of the ingredients associated with crime fiction: a detective, a series of mysterious deaths, a confined setting and a puzzle at its heart. Yet the novel's interests lie elsewhere, and it ultimately feels far more like a piece of atmospheric historical fiction than a traditional mystery.

Set aboard a Dutch trading ship in 1634, the novel initially appears to offer a fascinating historical mystery. However, the historical setting often feels more decorative than essential. Beyond the costumes, ships and period details, relatively little of the plot depends upon the specific era in which the story takes place. The seventeenth century provides atmosphere rather than driving the narrative itself.

Perhaps the biggest surprise is the role of the detective. One of the book's central figures is the renowned investigator Samuel Pipps, yet for much of the novel he is imprisoned and unable to actively participate in the investigation. Readers expecting a brilliant detective methodically unravelling clues may be frustrated by how little actual detection takes place. There is a clever twist behind this choice, but it nevertheless leaves the book feeling oddly disconnected from its supposed detective story foundations.

What Turton is really interested in is atmosphere. The ship becomes a floating world of paranoia, fear and superstition. Rumours spread of a demonic presence stalking the vessel, and much of the story revolves around questions of faith, fear and the supernatural. The result is a novel rich in mood and tension, even if the central mystery occasionally takes a back seat.

This creates something of an identity crisis. The book clearly wants to be a crime novel, but the mystery elements often feel secondary to the atmosphere and character interactions. Readers looking for a tightly plotted detective story may find themselves waiting for a level of investigation that never fully arrives.

The cast of characters reinforces this impression. The novel is packed with larger-than-life figures and familiar historical-fiction archetypes. There are tales of monsters and supernatural forces, eccentric personalities, and characters who seem designed to enrich the atmosphere rather than advance the mystery. The infamous Leper, who is said to haunt the ship, looms over much of the narrative, while a colourful supporting cast adds to the sense of an enclosed world descending into panic.

Because of this, The Devil and the Dark Water often feels closer in spirit to epic historical fiction than to classic detective fiction. Readers who enjoy becoming immersed in a vividly realised setting and spending time with a cast of unusual characters will likely find much to admire. Those coming to it in search of the next great locked-room mystery may feel somewhat short-changed.

That is not to say the novel is poorly written. Turton is highly skilled at creating tension and atmosphere, and the ship itself becomes an unforgettable setting. The problem is more one of expectations. The book is far more successful as an atmospheric historical adventure than it is as a conventional crime novel.

The Devil and the Dark Water is an ambitious and atmospheric novel that blends historical fiction, supernatural horror and mystery elements into something unusual. While it is frequently billed as crime fiction, the detective story often takes a back seat to mood, character and setting. Readers looking for a richly atmospheric historical novel will find plenty to enjoy, but crime fiction fans may be left wishing for a stronger focus on the mystery itself. It is a fascinating read, just perhaps not the detective novel it is often advertised to be.




No comments:

Post a Comment