Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars
Country of Origin: United States
Synopsis
New York City, 1896. Hypocrisy in high places is rife, police corruption commonplace, and a brutal killer is terrorising young male prostitutes. Forensics and psychological profiling are still in their infancy, but as the body count rises, Police Commissioner Theodore Roosevelt calls on eminent psychologist or 'alienist', Dr Laszlo Kreizler and crime reporter John Schuyler Moore to trial these new methods. Kreizler, Moore and their team must venture to the darkest corners of New York - and the human mind - to catch the sadistic killer before they strike again.
Review
Who Writes The Alienist?
Caleb Carr is American novelist and military historian. He has worked at the Council on Foreign Relations, Foreign Affairs Quarterly, MHQ: The Quarterly Journal of Military History, and taught military history, including World Military History, the History of American Intelligence, and Insurgency/Counterinsurgency, at Bard College. He was born in Manhattan, and for the majority of his life he lived on the Lower East Side of that city, spending his summers and many weekends at his family's home in Cherry Plain, New York. In 2000, he purchased his own property, known as Misery Mountain, in Cherry Plain; and in 2006 he moved there permanently.
What Is The Alienist About?
The Alienist is the first novel in Caleb Carr's Dr Laszlo Kreizler series and remains one of the most ambitious historical crime novels of recent decades. Set in New York at the end of the nineteenth century, the novel follows Kreizler and a small team of investigators as they attempt to hunt down a serial killer using what were then revolutionary ideas about criminal psychology and forensic science.
From the very first pages, it is evident that Carr has thoroughly researched the period. The novel is steeped in the history of New York, and hardly a chapter passes without references to the city's geography, social conditions, politics or prominent historical figures. The period detail is extensive and often fascinating. Readers gain a vivid picture of New York at a time when enormous wealth existed alongside poverty, crime and corruption.
Indeed, the city itself almost becomes a character. The Alienist feels inseparable from its setting, and it is difficult to imagine the story working nearly as well anywhere else. Carr successfully captures the sights, sounds and attitudes of turn-of-the-century New York, giving the novel a distinct historical flavour that lingers long after the final page.
The central investigation revolves around the early development of criminal profiling and forensic techniques. In many ways, this is Criminal Minds before Criminal Minds existed. Dr Kreizler and his colleagues attempt to understand the psychology of the killer, while also using scientific methods that were still viewed with considerable scepticism by law enforcement and society at large. This aspect of the novel is genuinely intriguing and remains one of its greatest strengths.
Unfortunately, the plot sometimes becomes overshadowed by the sheer weight of the historical detail. While the setting is impressively realised, there are periods where the investigation loses momentum and becomes difficult to follow. At times, the novel appears more interested in demonstrating its historical research than advancing the story, which can make sections feel unnecessarily slow.
This issue is compounded by the book's length. At well over 500 pages, The Alienist often feels significantly longer than it needs to be. There is undoubtedly an excellent thriller buried within its pages, but it could probably have reached the same destination with two hundred fewer pages. There are stretches where the narrative drags and where readers may find their attention wandering away from the mystery itself.
That said, the novel remains an impressive achievement. The combination of historical fiction, serial-killer investigation and early forensic science creates something distinctive and memorable. Even when the pacing falters, the originality of the concept and the richness of the setting keep the reader engaged.
Ultimately, The Alienist is a novel that is easier to admire than to love. Its research is impeccable, its setting superbly realised and its central premise fascinating. Yet its excessive length prevents it from being the gripping thriller it might otherwise have been.
A fascinating blend of historical fiction and psychological crime novel that vividly recreates nineteenth-century New York. While the pioneering forensic themes and rich historical setting are compelling, the story often gets lost beneath the weight of its research, resulting in a novel that feels considerably longer than it needed to be.

No comments:
Post a Comment