Monday, August 17, 2026

Book Review: The Marlow Murder Club Robert Thorogood (Marlow Murder Club 1) * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Seventy-seven-year-old Judith Potts is blissfully happy. She lives alone in a faded mansion in Marlow, sets crosswords for The Times, and there’s no man in her life to tell her what to do or how much whisky to drink.  One evening, while out swimming in the Thames, Judith witnesses a brutal murder. When the local police don’t believe her story, Judith and two unlikely friends decide to investigate for themselves. Together, they are the Marlow Murder Club.

Review

Who Writes The Marlow Murder Club?

Robert Thorogood is the author of THE MARLOW MURDER CLUB books, set in my hometown of Marlow in Buckinghamshire.  The first book in the series has been made into a TV show and can be watched in the UK on the Freeview channel U&Drama and in the USA on PBS/Masterpiece. A second TV series is coming out in 2025 and is based on Death Comes to Marlow, but also includes some brand new murders as well.

What is The Marlow Murder Club About?

Robert Thorogood is, of course, best known as the creator and writer of Death in Paradise. Week after week, that series delivers intricate murder mysteries, elaborate alibis and the occasional locked-room puzzle. Given that reputation, it is perhaps surprising that his first novel series takes a rather different approach.

If you are expecting The Marlow Murder Club to be Death in Paradise in book form, you may be disappointed. There are no devilishly complicated locked-room mysteries here, nor are there the kind of elaborate puzzle plots that have become Thorogood's trademark on television. Instead, he serves up something altogether gentler: a cosy mystery set in the affluent riverside town of Marlow.

In many ways, the novel feels closer in spirit to Richard Osman's The Thursday Murder Club than to Death in Paradise. The focus is on a group of amateur sleuths, their relationships and the community in which they live rather than on constructing an impossibly complicated mystery. The result is a warm and highly readable novel that places character as much at the forefront as crime.

The story centres on Judith Potts, an unconventional and fiercely independent crossword compiler who becomes convinced that a murder has taken place after hearing a gunshot from her riverside home. Joining forces with a small group of equally unlikely investigators, she begins to uncover secrets hidden beneath Marlow's respectable exterior.

Thorogood writes with obvious affection for both the genre and his characters. The amateur detectives are engaging company, and the town itself is vividly brought to life. This is very much a comfort read, the sort of mystery where spending time with the characters can be just as enjoyable as following the investigation.

As with Death in Paradise, it is possible to identify some of the broad outlines of the plot before the final reveal. Experienced crime-fiction readers may find themselves guessing how the murders are connected and what general direction the story is heading. However, knowing the destination is not the same as understanding the journey. Thorogood still keeps enough secrets hidden to ensure that the precise details remain difficult to predict.

The novel also benefits from a satisfying twist towards the end that recontextualises what has come before. While the mystery may not be the most complex ever written, it is cleverly constructed and entertaining throughout.

Ultimately, The Marlow Murder Club succeeds because it knows exactly what it wants to be. Rather than attempting to replicate Death in Paradise, Thorogood embraces the cosy-mystery genre and creates a charming, character-driven detective story that stands comfortably on its own merits.

A delightful and engaging cosy mystery that showcases a different side of Robert Thorogood's writing. Fans expecting a literary version of Death in Paradise may be surprised, but those looking for charming characters, an appealing setting and an enjoyable mystery will find plenty to love in The Marlow Murder Club.





No comments:

Post a Comment