Thursday, September 10, 2026

Book Review: Murder Like Clockwork Nicola Whyte (Marchfield Square Mystery 2) * * * *


 Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars

Country Of Origin: United Kingdom

Synopsis

Every Thursday at midday Audrey Brooks cleans the Petrov house. Mr Petrov is never home - in fact he seems to use the house purely as storage for his impressive collection of antiques - but that doesn't affect the care with which Audrey mops, polishes, and carefully winds each of the dozens of beautiful clocks that decorate the tall, elegant, empty London mansion.  Until the morning she finds a corpse in the back bedroom, the pristine walls and floor covered in blood, and flees the house in panic.  Fifteen minutes later, the police arrive... and find nothing. No body. No blood. The only thing slightly out of the ordinary is the clock in that back bedroom, which is now running four minutes slow.

Review

Who Write Murder Like Clockwork?

Nicola Whyte studied drama at University and spent many years as a bookseller before becoming a web developer.  She co owns a digital agency.

What is Murder Like Clockwork About?

How nice it is to find a crime novel that completely grabs hold of you from the first page and refuses to let go. Murder Like Clockwork is exactly that sort of book. It is the kind of mystery that starts with an intriguing premise and then steadily builds until you find yourself unable to put it down. This was one of those rare novels that can be comfortably read in a single sitting simply because the story is so enjoyable.

The novel's greatest strength is undoubtedly its central mystery. While it is not quite a classic locked-room puzzle, it belongs to that family of crime fiction. The question at its heart is wonderfully simple and irresistible: how do you make a body disappear in fifteen minutes?

It is the sort of seemingly impossible crime that immediately hooks mystery fans. The setup feels clever rather than contrived, and as the investigation unfolds, the answers gradually emerge in a way that is satisfying and believable. Importantly, the solution never feels outlandish. There is always a risk with impossible-crime mysteries that the explanation will disappoint, but that is not the case here. The revelation is well thought out and makes perfect sense within the world of the story.

The plotting throughout is equally strong. Nicola Whyte carefully layers clues and misdirection, ensuring that readers remain engaged from beginning to end. The mystery unfolds at exactly the right pace, revealing enough information to keep the story moving while holding back enough secrets to maintain the suspense.

What is particularly interesting is where the novel sits within the crime-fiction spectrum. It has one foot firmly planted in the cosy mystery genre, with its emphasis on puzzle-solving and character interactions. Yet it never feels entirely like a cosy mystery. There is a slightly sharper edge to proceedings and a stronger emphasis on the mystery itself than is often found in more traditional cosy series.

As a result, the book occupies a satisfying middle ground. Readers who enjoy cosy mysteries will appreciate the warmth and accessibility, while those who prefer more conventional crime fiction will find enough investigative substance to keep them invested.

The writing itself is straightforward and engaging, allowing the mystery to take centre stage. Rather than becoming weighed down by unnecessary subplots or excessive detail, the novel focuses on delivering a strong puzzle and letting the reader enjoy the process of trying to solve it.

Murder Like Clockwork is an excellent mystery built around a genuinely intriguing impossible-crime premise. The question of how a body can vanish in fifteen minutes drives the narrative beautifully, and the eventual explanation is both clever and convincing. Straddling the line between cosy mystery and traditional crime fiction, it offers the best of both worlds and proves incredibly difficult to put down. A thoroughly enjoyable and highly recommended mystery.




No comments:

Post a Comment