Star Rating: * * * * out of 5 stars
Country of Origin: Ireland
Synopsis
When celebrity gardener Finn O’Leary returns to his hometown of Abbeyford, Ireland, to care for his ageing mother, he is quickly roped into the local Tidy Towns committee. With the competition fiercely fought for by every town and village in the country, Finn’s best friend’s sister, Aoife, is determined that this will finally be Abbeyford’s year. But Finn has barely unpacked before an alto-baritone drops dead during his mother’s choir practice, midway through a rendition of ‘What the World Needs Now’. Soon, there is far more at stake than flowerbeds and civic pride. With his mother, her carer, Happiness, and Aoife in tow, Finn sets out to discover who has brought murder to Abbeyford.
Review
Who Writes A Plot To Die For?
Ardal O’Hanlon is one of Ireland’s best-loved actors and stand-up comedians, as well as a writer of novels and documentaries. Ardal's acting credits include leading roles in Father Ted (C4), for which he won a British Comedy Award and Bafta nominations, Death in Paradise (BBC), My Hero (BBC), Derry Girls (C4), Big Bad World (ITV), Blessed (BBC) and the RTE sitcom Val Falvey TD.
What is A Plot to Die For About?
Ever since Richard Osman proved that television personalities could become serious players in the crime fiction market with The Thursday Murder Club, there has been a steady stream of broadcasters, journalists and celebrities turning their hands to murder mysteries. Jeremy Vine, Robert Peston, Susie Dent and many others have all joined the trend. With A Plot to Die For, actor and comedian Ardal O'Hanlon throws his hat into the ring.
At first glance, the novel sits comfortably within the increasingly crowded cosy mystery genre. It contains many of the familiar ingredients that readers have come to expect: a close-knit community, eccentric characters, amateur sleuthing and a murder that needs solving. The danger with such a popular genre is that it can become overstuffed and repetitive, with one series blending into another.
Fortunately, O'Hanlon brings something distinctive to the table.
The novel's greatest strength is its unmistakable sense of Irishness. O'Hanlon's background and personality shine through in the writing, and the characters feel rooted in an Irish worldview rather than simply being generic cosy mystery figures transplanted to an Irish setting. There is a humour, rhythm and attitude to the dialogue that gives the book a unique flavour among contemporary cosy mysteries.
To his credit, O'Hanlon largely avoids falling into the trap of turning his characters into exaggerated Father Ted-style caricatures. There are a handful of moments where the humour edges close to stereotype, but for the most part the characters feel authentic and believable. The result is a novel that celebrates its Irish setting without reducing it to a collection of familiar clichés.
The biggest surprise, however, is the subject matter. Given O'Hanlon's background as an actor and performer, one might reasonably have expected a mystery set in the world of television, theatre or entertainment. Instead, he builds his novel around gardening and horticulture.
It is not an obvious choice, and at times it feels as though O'Hanlon would have been operating on more familiar ground had he chosen the world of acting as his backdrop. Gardening can seem a slightly unusual foundation upon which to build a murder mystery.
Yet there is also something appealing about that decision. The setting helps differentiate the novel from many other cosy mysteries and provides opportunities for characters and situations that feel fresh. Even if it does not always play to O'Hanlon's most obvious strengths, it gives the book its own identity.
As a mystery, the novel is enjoyable and easy to read, though it does not necessarily reinvent the genre. The real attraction is the warmth of the writing and the distinctive voice that O'Hanlon brings to his first crime novel.
A Plot to Die For is a charming addition to the cosy mystery genre that benefits enormously from Ardal O'Hanlon's uniquely Irish perspective. While the gardening backdrop is perhaps a surprising choice and the mystery itself follows familiar cosy conventions, the novel's strong sense of place, engaging characters and gentle humour help it stand out in an increasingly crowded market. Fans of The Thursday Murder Club and other modern cosy mysteries will find plenty to enjoy, while readers looking for something with a distinctly Irish flavour may find it particularly appealing.


No comments:
Post a Comment