Tuesday, September 29, 2026

TV Series Review: This is Not a Murder Mystery * * *

 


Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars

Country of Origin: Belgium

Synopsis

Wealthy art patron Lord James invites a group of unknown surrealist painters to her lavish country estate to showcase their work.  Soon, however, they start dying and the police are called in to investigate.


Review

Who Writes This is Not A Murder Mystery?

The series is written and produced by Christophe Dirickx and Matthias Lebeer based on their idea and was broadcast on Studiocanal.

What is This is Not A Murder Mystery About?

Despite its title, This Is Not a Murder Mystery is very much a murder mystery, albeit one wrapped in a lavish and highly stylised celebration of surrealist art and 1930s culture. What immediately sets the series apart is its setting. Rather than relying on the familiar country houses and aristocratic families of most Golden Age-inspired mysteries, it immerses viewers in the eccentric and often bizarre world of the surrealist movement.

This alone makes the series stand out in a crowded field. The suspects are not colonels, dowagers and butlers but artists who would go on to become some of the most influential figures of the twentieth century. Familiar names such as Salvador Dalí and René Magritte appear among the cast of characters, creating a fascinating blend of historical figures and fictional mystery.

The series fully embraces its artistic inspiration. The murders themselves often feel like works of surrealist art, with victims discovered in elaborate and visually striking tableaux that would not look out of place hanging in an avant-garde gallery. There is a dreamlike quality to many of the crimes, and the production revels in imagery that is strange, unsettling and often beautiful.

Visually, the series is outstanding. Every episode is gorgeously shot, with lavish costumes, striking set design and cinematography that captures both the glamour and eccentricity of the period. It is one of those productions where the visual presentation is almost as important as the mystery itself. The result is a show that frequently feels closer to an art-house drama than a conventional detective series.

The focus on character and artistic expression does present a challenge, however. With such flamboyant subject matter and larger-than-life characters, there is a tendency for some performances to become overly theatrical. At times, certain actors appear to be enjoying the opportunity to inhabit eccentric artists a little too much, resulting in performances that stray into overacting. While this occasionally fits the surreal tone of the series, there are moments when it undermines the credibility of the mystery.

Fortunately, the strength of the setting and atmosphere largely compensates for these excesses. The series is never less than entertaining, and even when characters verge on caricature, the sheer originality of the concept carries it forward.

The mystery itself is perhaps less successful than the surrounding spectacle. While the journey is enjoyable, attentive viewers may find the identity of the killer becomes increasingly obvious as the series progresses. In the end, the solution follows a fairly traditional Golden Age pattern, which feels slightly at odds with the otherwise inventive and unconventional nature of the show.

This Is Not a Murder Mystery is a visually stunning and refreshingly original crime drama that successfully combines Golden Age mystery elements with the strange and fascinating world of 1930s surrealist art. Its cast of famous artists, striking murder scenes and avant-garde sensibilities make it unlike almost anything else on television. While some of the performances stray into overacting and the solution becomes a little too predictable, the series remains an imaginative and highly enjoyable mystery. As a piece of artistic crime fiction, it is far more memorable than its somewhat conventional ending might suggest.

No comments:

Post a Comment