Star Rating: * * * out of 5 stars
Country of Origin: United Kingdom
Synopsis
A serial killer is burning people alive in the Lake District's prehistoric stone circles. He leaves no clues and the police are helpless. When his name is found carved into the charred remains of the third victim, disgraced detective Washington Poe is brought back from suspension and into an investigation he wants no part of. Reluctantly partnered with the brilliant, but socially awkward, civilian analyst, Tilly Bradshaw, the mismatched pair uncover a trail that only he is meant to see. The elusive killer has a plan and for some reason Poe is part of it.
Review
Who Writes The Puppet Show?
Multi-award-winning author M.W. Craven was born in Carlisle but grew up in Newcastle. He joined the army at sixteen, leaving ten years later to complete a social work degree. Seventeen years after taking up a probation officer role in Cumbria, at the rank of assistant chief officer, he became a full-time author. He is an instant Sunday Times bestseller and, for his Cumbria-set Washington Poe series, a recipient of the 2019 Crime Writers' Association Gold Dagger, the 2022 Ian Fleming Steel Dagger, the 2023 Theakston Old Peculier Crime Novel of the Year and the 2025 Fingerprint Crime Book of the Year. The series has now been translated into thirty languages and sold over one million copies.
What is The Puppet Show About?
The wild but picturesque landscapes of the Lake District take centre stage in M.W. Craven's The Puppet Show. This is a novel in which the setting is every bit as important as the mystery itself. Beneath the beauty of the fells and lakes lies a darker reality, as a serial killer known as the Immolation Man terrorises the region.
At its heart, The Puppet Show is a fairly traditional serial killer thriller. The premise is familiar enough, with investigators racing against time to stop a murderer while uncovering the truth behind a series of horrific crimes. Yet what makes the novel stand out is undoubtedly its plot. Craven delivers a genuinely gripping mystery packed with twists, revelations and surprises that elevate it above many of its contemporaries. The central concept is so strong that it keeps the pages turning even when other elements are less successful.
The novel introduces Washington Poe, a former National Crime Agency investigator who has effectively retired after a disastrous case threatened to end his career. When the Immolation Man begins his murderous campaign, Poe is reluctantly drawn back into service to assist the investigation. Alongside him is the brilliant analyst Tilly Bradshaw, a socially awkward genius whose exceptional intelligence often proves just as valuable as Poe's investigative instincts.
While both characters are entertaining, neither feels entirely original. The damaged detective struggling with professional and personal issues has become a familiar fixture of modern crime fiction, while Bradshaw fits into the tradition of eccentric, intellectually gifted sidekicks. Readers well-versed in the genre may feel they have encountered similar characters before.
That said, Craven's real strength lies elsewhere. The atmosphere throughout the novel is superb. The Lake District is not simply a backdrop but an active part of the story, shaping both the investigation and the mystery itself. The rugged landscape creates a sense of isolation and menace that perfectly complements the darker aspects of the plot. Few crime novels make such effective use of their setting.
The pacing is generally strong, although there are moments when the character work feels slightly underdeveloped. This perhaps explains why The Puppet Show falls just short of greatness. The mystery is compelling enough to carry the novel, but stronger characterisation might have elevated it into the very top tier of crime thrillers.
Nevertheless, the sheer ingenuity of the plot cannot be overstated. Craven constructs a mystery that is both clever and unpredictable, rewarding readers who enjoy intricate investigations and shocking revelations.
A dark, atmospheric thriller with an outstanding central mystery and a vividly realised Lake District setting. While the characters occasionally feel familiar, the strength of the plot and the immersive atmosphere make The Puppet Show an excellent start to the Washington Poe series.


No comments:
Post a Comment