Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Our Top TV Detectives

 Ranking television detectives is always subjective. Some are brilliant puzzle-solvers, others are memorable because of their personalities, and a few transformed crime drama altogether. Taking influence, longevity, characterisation, and the quality of their series into account, here is my ranking of the greatest TV detectives.

1. Inspector Morse (Inspector Morse)

The benchmark for television detectives. Intelligent, flawed, cultured, and endlessly fascinating, Morse elevated TV crime drama beyond simple whodunits. John Thaw's performance remains one of the finest in television history.

2. Sherlock Holmes (The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes)

Jeremy Brett's portrayal is widely regarded as the definitive screen Holmes. Brilliant, eccentric, and utterly compelling, he captured Arthur Conan Doyle's detective perfectly.

Read our review

3. Hercule Poirot (Agatha Christie's Poirot)

David Suchet achieved the seemingly impossible by becoming Poirot. Across thirteen seasons he delivered a character who was both faithful to the novels and unmistakably his own.

4. Columbo (Columbo)

The detective who always seemed one step behind while actually being ten steps ahead. Peter Falk's shabby raincoat and deceptively simple manner created one of television's most original crime solvers.

5. Jane Tennison (Prime Suspect)

Helen Mirren's detective changed crime television forever. Tennison's intelligence, determination, and realism made her one of the greatest police characters ever created.

6. Saga Norén (The Bridge)

An iconic modern detective. Her social difficulties and relentless pursuit of the truth made her one of the most memorable investigators of the twenty-first century.

7. Endeavour Morse (Endeavour)

A remarkable achievement. Shaun Evans managed to create a younger version of Morse who felt authentic while standing as a character in his own right.

8. Vera Stanhope (Vera)

Brenda Blethyn turned Ann Cleeves' detective into a national treasure. Gruff, lonely, and exceptionally perceptive, Vera became one of British television's defining detectives.

9. Kurt Wallander (Wallander)

Whether portrayed by Krister Henriksson or Kenneth Branagh, Wallander epitomised Scandinavian noir, combining brilliant detective work with personal vulnerability.

10. Jimmy Perez (Shetland)

Douglas Henshall brought warmth and humanity to Ann Cleeves' detective. His understated approach made him one of television's most believable investigators.

11. Detective Chief Inspector Barnaby (Midsomer Murders)

Both Tom Barnaby and John Barnaby deserve recognition. For decades they have guided viewers through Britain's most murderous county with charm and intelligence.

12. Luther (Luther)

Idris Elba's detective is larger than life, operating on instinct and emotion. Not always realistic, but undeniably compelling.

13. Alex Drake (Ashes to Ashes)

Part detective, part science-fiction protagonist, Drake helped create one of television's most inventive crime dramas.

14. DCI Jack Frost (A Touch of Frost)

David Jason's scruffy detective combined compassion with dogged determination in one of Britain's most enduring crime series.

15. DI Alec Hardy (Broadchurch)

David Tennant's troubled detective provided the emotional backbone of one of the greatest crime dramas of recent decades.

Read our review 

16. DCI Tom Lynley (The Inspector Lynley Mysteries)

An aristocrat investigating crime alongside Barbara Havers should never have worked, yet it became one of television's strongest detective partnerships.  He would appear first in The Inspector Lynley Mysteries and then in the new series Lynley.

17. Sonny Crockett (Miami Vice)

Not a traditional detective, but his cultural influence on television crime drama is impossible to ignore.

18. Jessica Fletcher (Murder, She Wrote)

The greatest amateur detective in television history. Angela Lansbury's mystery writer solved more murders than some entire police forces.

19. Adrian Monk (Monk)

A unique detective whose obsessive-compulsive disorder became both a strength and a weakness in solving crimes.

20. Astrid Nielsen (Astrid et Raphaëlle)

One of the most interesting modern detectives. Her ability to see patterns and details overlooked by others gives the series its distinctive identity.  The series would be remade by the British as the TV series Patience 

Read our review 

Honourable Mentions

Just missing the top twenty:

  • Lewis (Lewis)
  • Castle (Castle)
  • Patrick Jane (The Mentalist)
  • Temperance Brennan (Bones)
  • Cormoran Strike (Strike)
  • Brenda Leigh Johnson (The Closer)
  • Jane Rizzoli (Rizzoli & Isles)
  • Jim Bergerac (Bergerac)
  • Richard Poole (Death in Paradise)
  • Patience Evans (Patience)

The Greatest of Them All

If one detective deserves the crown, it is Inspector Morse. While Sherlock Holmes may be the most famous detective in fiction and Poirot the most successful literary sleuth, Morse is arguably television's greatest detective. His combination of intellect, flaws, humour, melancholy, and humanity created a character who remains the standard against which all television detectives are measured. More than thirty years after his debut, his influence can still be felt in everything from Endeavour to Strike, Vera, and countless other British crime dramas.

No comments:

Post a Comment