Friday, November 6, 2026

Reading Order Guide: Cora Felton aka The Puzzle Lady

 The Puzzle Lady series is one of the most charming and unusual cosy mystery series in modern crime fiction. Written by Parnell Hall, the books combine traditional whodunits, crossword puzzles, eccentric characters and plenty of humour. At the centre of the series is Cora Felton, a woman who becomes famous as a crossword expert despite one rather significant problem: she cannot actually solve crossword puzzles.

This unlikely premise provides the foundation for a long-running series that delights readers with clever mysteries and colourful characters.

Who is the Puzzle Lady?

Cora Felton

Cora Felton is a middle-aged woman with a fondness for cigarettes, gambling and avoiding responsibility. Through a misunderstanding, she becomes nationally known as the "Puzzle Lady," a celebrated crossword expert.

There is just one complication:

She knows almost nothing about crossword puzzles.

The actual puzzle expert is her niece, Sherry Carter, who often has to rescue Cora from the consequences of her deception.

Despite her lack of puzzle-solving ability, Cora possesses a sharp intelligence, an instinct for people and an uncanny habit of stumbling into murder investigations.

Sherry Carter

Cora's niece is the real crossword expert behind the Puzzle Lady's reputation. More sensible and organised than her aunt, Sherry frequently assists with both puzzles and murder investigations.

Reading Order

1. A Clue for the Puzzle Lady (1999)

The first novel introduces Cora Felton when the murder of a wealthy neighbour leads police to suspect someone close to her.

Why start here?

  • Introduces Cora and Sherry.
  • Establishes the central joke of the series.
  • A clever and entertaining mystery.

2. Last Puzzle & Testament (2000)

A murder and a puzzling will provide another challenge for the Puzzle Lady.

3. Puzzled to Death (2001)

A crossword tournament becomes the backdrop for murder.

4. With This Puzzle, I Thee Kill (2002)

A wedding, family tensions and murder create another enjoyable mystery.

5. And a Puzzle to Die On (2003)

A suspicious death and a set of clues place Cora in the middle of another investigation.

6. Stalking the Puzzle Lady (2004)

One of the more personal entries as Cora finds herself the target of unwanted attention.

7. You Have the Right to Remain Puzzled (2006)

8. The Sudoku Puzzle Murders (2008)

The series expands beyond crosswords to incorporate the popularity of Sudoku puzzles.

9. The Kakuro Puzzle Murders (2009)

10. The KenKen Killings (2010)

11. The Puzzle Lady vs. the Sudoku Lady (2011)

A rivalry between puzzle experts helps drive the mystery.

12. NYPD Puzzle (2012)

Cora becomes involved in a case connected to New York.

13. Puzzle Lady Most Likely to Die (2014)

One of the final entries in the series.

Best Reading Order

Although many mysteries stand alone, publication order is recommended:

  1. A Clue for the Puzzle Lady
  2. Last Puzzle & Testament
  3. Puzzled to Death
  4. With This Puzzle, I Thee Kill
  5. And a Puzzle to Die On
  6. Stalking the Puzzle Lady
  7. You Have the Right to Remain Puzzled
  8. The Sudoku Puzzle Murders
  9. The Kakuro Puzzle Murders
  10. The KenKen Killings
  11. The Puzzle Lady vs. the Sudoku Lady
  12. NYPD Puzzle
  13. Puzzle Lady Most Likely to Die

Best Books for New Readers

Start Here

A Clue for the Puzzle Lady

The perfect introduction to the series and its central joke.

Best Traditional Mystery

Puzzled to Death

A wonderful blend of crime and crossword puzzles.

Funniest Entry

The Puzzle Lady vs. the Sudoku Lady

An especially entertaining later novel.

Best Puzzle-Themed Story

The Sudoku Puzzle Murders

A good example of how Hall expanded the concept beyond crosswords.

What Makes the Series Different?

Humour

Unlike many amateur-sleuth mysteries, much of the appeal comes from the comedy generated by Cora's attempts to maintain her reputation as a puzzle genius.

Real Puzzles

Many books include actual puzzles for readers to attempt, making the series especially enjoyable for crossword enthusiasts.

An Unusual Detective

Cora is not a retired teacher, librarian or police officer. She is a reluctant sleuth who often finds herself investigating crimes simply because circumstances leave her no choice.

Strong Supporting Cast

The relationship between Cora and Sherry provides much of the series' warmth and humour.

Themes Throughout the Series

The novels frequently explore:

  • Family relationships
  • Secrets and deception
  • Small-town life
  • Friendship
  • Amateur sleuthing
  • The joy of puzzles

Unlike darker crime novels, these books emphasise fun and entertainment while still providing satisfying mysteries.

Similar Series

Readers who enjoy The Puzzle Lady should try:

Why The Puzzle Lady Endures

The Puzzle Lady novels succeed because they combine two pleasures: solving mysteries and solving puzzles. Parnell Hall created a memorable protagonist whose flaws make her far more entertaining than a traditional genius detective. Readers quickly become invested in Cora's adventures, even as they wonder how she continues to maintain the illusion that she is a crossword expert.

For fans of cosy mysteries, clever puzzles and light-hearted crime fiction, The Puzzle Lady series remains one of the genre's most distinctive and enjoyable creations. It offers exactly what many readers seek from a mystery novel: engaging characters, clever plotting and a great deal of fun along the way.

No comments:

Post a Comment